A new neighbor moved in and is really advocating for them, but I think most people in the HOA are split. It's come up after some recent thefts after someone left a garage door open. I'm thinking of organizing my arguments like this:
- Even with a camera capturing a thief's face, police are unlikely to actually catch the person or retreive the stolen property.
- Invasion of personal privacy, I don't like being tracked and my whereabouts being monitored
- Surrendering biometric data without my consent
- Police / ICE using the data without permission to harass our residents
How does this sound? It's so exhausting fighting against this. Does anyone have any other good points or articles that can provide support? Many thanks in advance
These "user-friendly" network cameras are frequently bought and set up by people who have no idea what they're doing, which leads to thousands of them being accessible to anyone on the Internet:
Bitsight Identifies Thousands of Security Cameras Openly Accessible on the Internet
Wyze cameras let some owners see into a stranger’s home — again
Security startup Verkada hack exposes 150,000 security cameras in Tesla factories, jails, and more
Somebody’s Watching: Hackers Breach Ring Home Security Cameras
Even the companies that make and distribute these cameras don't secure them properly.
In some of these cases getting access to the camera barely even qualifies as hacking. If you know the web address of the camera you can just type it into your web browser and get the live video feed because it's just being streamed to the public Internet, no authentication or encryption. That means someone on the other side of the planet or someone in the house next door can just start watching what's going on in your house.
If the HOA insists on installing cameras, you should insist that they hire a professional to install and configure them correctly and maintain them long-term to prevent security breaches. Someone has to keep the firmware/software up to date when the manufacturer releases security patches and bug fixes, not just for the cameras but also for the network they're connected to. This means you don't just need to pay for one-time installation, you need to hire an employee long-term.
I would also ask the pushy neighbor if he was specifically planning on buying Wyze cameras for this. They've had multiple security problems in recent years.
A halfway intelligent thief could just use the camera to see where things worth stealing are kept and what time of day is best for breaking in unnoticed. If this is not done properly it will make the security worse, not better.
Yes! Thank you so much these are great points! And yeah, they are proposing Wyze cameras
Might also be worth pointing out in an HOA meeting that if this guy buys and configures the cameras himself then he has access to watch everybody. How much does the rest of the community trust this guy to not be creeping on everyone else?