this post was submitted on 18 Sep 2024
34 points (64.4% liked)

Vegan

453 readers
7 users here now

The vegan place to discuss things.

Vegans Only

Resources:

Vegan Cheat Sheet

Animal Products to Avoid

Vegan Company Guide

Rules:

  1. Be Vegan.

  2. Don't be not vegan.

  3. Arguments and debates will be removed.

  4. No bigotry.

  5. No JAQ offs or Sealioning. (Just asking Questions)

  6. No promoting of plant based capitalism.

  7. Vegans only.

  8. Vegan btw.

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] NaevaTheRat@vegantheoryclub.org 3 points 6 months ago

What do to mean when you say "emotional argument"? I understand it as something like "an argument which rests on an appeal to an emotional experience" or similar.

For example a mathematical proof is not an emotional argument, as a being without any emotions would be able to verify it as true.

However "people don't want to die, so you shouldn't kill them" is an emotional argument as it fundamentally rests on the counterfactual "a person assumed to have qualia observing a universe in which they had been killed might experience negative valence". Which only makes sense if the notion of another being you assume to have qualia being sad in a way which is impossible in reality upsets you.