210
submitted 11 months ago* (last edited 11 months ago) by star_wraith@hexbear.net to c/history@hexbear.net

If you grew up in the United States, it's likely that you have often heard Americans - when referring to conflict in Palestine - say something to the effect of:

"Well, Jews and Muslims have fighting over that land for thousands of years. They hate each other and there's no way we'll ever have peace there."

I think you all be surprised to learn that Americans are complete dumbasses when it comes to history, because this notion of Jews and Muslims struggling in eternal conflict over a piece of land is an absolute myth.

Up until the last hundred years or so, then stretching back to Roman Empire times, Jews and Muslims (and Christians) have lived together in Palestine. From the third or fourth century CE until the emergence of Islam, Jews and Christians both lived there (oftentimes it was Jewish people who converted to Christianity). After Islam emerges then you had three groups living there, in various proportions, with the Muslim proportion steadily getting larger over the centuries; and there really doesn’t seem to be intra-group conflict beyond a sort of baseline for humans.

Of course there was conflict and war. You had Turks and Crusaders and others fighting plenty of wars in the area. But it doesn't seem to me like there was any more amount of war in Palestine during that time than there was, say, in the Rhine Valley. And also, just because there are wars doesn't mean that there is conflict between groups of people. In general, it seems like for centuries, Jews, Muslims and Christians occupying the same space in relative peace seems to be the norm. Even up until before the Balfour declaration, there were a number of Jewish people living alongside Muslims in Palestine. But importantly, the Jewish people in Palestine didn't seek to dominate, but to either mind their own business quietly in their community, or even with a sort of shared Palestinian identity with their Muslim neighbors.

Co-existence has been the historical norm there, not conflict.

As best as I can tell, this whole notion of "they've been fighting forever" comes from one specific source: Evangelical Christians. It's because that group believes that roughly 4,000 years ago, the only humans alive were Noah and his family. Then in a few generations, Jacob and Esau fought over a birthright and then those two literally became the first ancestors of Jews and Muslims, respectively. There's some verse in there about "always struggling against each other" or something. These Evangelicals then go on to believe everything else in the Old Testament - despite the overwhelming historical evidence - is literally true. That the Jewish people were slaves in Egypt and then conquered Palestine (there's no evidence for Jews being slaves in Egypt and most historians believe the Jewish people emerged out of the larger Canaanite people, not as something separate from them). These Evangelicals can then excuse genocide if not encourage it since it’s inevitable anyway (and in that they side with Israel, because they’re all racist pieces of shit).

Once again, Evangelicals making the world worse for everyone.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] BrownMinusBlue@lemmygrad.ml 9 points 11 months ago

Can anyone help me with some good sources on this?

[-] poppy_apocalypse@hexbear.net 12 points 11 months ago

well, there's a lot of books, but you can look at my book 'overthrowing geography'. zach lockman, comrades and enemies, gershon shafir, land labor and the origin of the israeli-palestinian conflict, any of nur masalha's books, any of rashid khalidi's books, any of salim tamari's books, alexander scholch's book on late ottoman palestine, and beshara doumani's rediscovering palestine. that will get you off to a good start :-)

I've never been assigned soooo much reading for one class. Might as well have been a grad level course. If you want I can dm you my professor's email, he'd be more than happy to help you. He also has a book called, "Heavy Metal Islam" about music and resistance in the Middle East, if you're interested.

[-] BrownMinusBlue@lemmygrad.ml 3 points 11 months ago

I have never been assigned so much reading in my life and I'm a law student. Your help is much appreciated and I'm also interested in your professor's email.

this post was submitted on 10 Oct 2023
210 points (100.0% liked)

history

22883 readers
66 users here now

Welcome to c/history! History is written by the posters.

c/history is a comm for discussion about history so feel free to talk and post about articles, books, videos, events or historical figures you find interesting

Please read the Hexbear Code of Conduct and remember...we're all comrades here.

Do not post reactionary or imperialist takes (criticism is fine, but don't pull nonsense from whatever chud author is out there).

When sharing historical facts, remember to provide credible souces or citations.

Historical Disinformation will be removed

founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS