I’d say it depends what look you are going for. For a classic dress watch, I’d consider it a bit too big. For a more leisure or sporty look it’s just on the upper limit but OK if you like your watch to be more prominent.
But that’s just my personal opinion - If you like it, what’s wrong with that?
I found piqué fabric generally less durable or at least more prone to quicker looking worn out than other fabrics. So BIFL polos are something I gave up on.
That being said, I‘ve gotten some good mileage out of Fred Perry and Lacoste Polos.
EDIT: a different tennis player all along