MJBrune

Elon Musk should get directly sued from the State of California for active sabotage of it's public infrastructure.

If he does have mental health issues stemming from this, then he should have just deleted all his accounts, accepted responsibility from his actions, and moved on to something else and work on his mental health.

I mean, I think he's done that. He's deactivated his Patreon, deleted his YouTube channel, and said that he'll comment more when his mental health is better. Maybe I am a soft-hearted fool but it sounds like he's done just that.

That said it's important to remember everyone is human and makes mistakes.

As for what I'd do differently. I don't know, I don't think anything else could have been done differently I supposed but it just feels not great.

I used to use XFCE religiously and since I've been popping my head back into Linux after moving to Windows, I have noticed I've been on Gnome and KDE far more. my XFCE days felt far more stable. That said, I don't think the DE is solely to blame.

If the installer is that easily scared off then it doesn't deserve to be an installer. I treat the Windows installer far worse.

Even re-reading what I said, I don't feel like I come off implying that at all. There needs to be room for conversation on how to handle the situation without saying that the victim's feelings are less valid than the attacker's. If there is a better way to word what I wrote to focus on that then please let me know.

I think TheRtRevKaiser said it best "This last video felt like watching somebody’s life being dismantled [..] honestly the whole thing just kind of made me feel sad, I didn’t get much satisfaction out of it." and that's exactly what I was trying to convey.

I used Linux as a daily driver for 5 years and was a FreeBSD porter for 2 years after that. I've been using Linux every year to pop in and see the issues and their current state. In this year alone, I've seen issues with Fedora, Linux Mint, and Manjaro. Hell, even right now the Fedora Live installer won't launch on my desktop. It hard freezes before it can even get the installer up.

I think the disconnect here is that others are saying “they aren’t supporting us,” and your response is pretty much “lol, abandon what you’re doing and go back to the corporations.”

My point is that Linux does nothing to make it easy to support. Nvidia even has made an open source kernel driver. https://github.com/NVIDIA/open-gpu-kernel-modules Nvidia is doing a lot of work to support Linux and people don't seem to see it.

Also “it works on windows” is a terrible rebuttal in a discussion where you first say “it works fine on x11”

A question to configure Nvidia Optimus is also a terrible rebuttal in the first place. Optimus is blocked because Linux kernel doesn't want proprietary blobs. AMD has the same exact issue.

So in the past, I used Linux as a daily driver for over 5 years. I was a Freebsd Ports Porter for a few years, and am now a C++ programmer on games in which I release Linux builds for. I'm not unfamiliar with making Linux work. It's not just drivers but a whole set of issues in which I had to drop Linux for Windows.

Also, the 1000s of different updates aren't hyperbole. I've absolutely had that on Manjaro. On Linux Mint I have updates almost daily but it's typically only a handful of things.

That's a great point too and does sway me a bit to feeling better about this all. Just feels like a huge bummer. But maybe it's a huge bummer that James needed to turn it around and be better.

I’m not sure I agree with you that Hbomb did anything wrong

I mean, I hope I don't come off as saying he did anything wrong. Just that it didn't feel good.

this last video felt like watching somebody’s life being dismantled.

This is exactly what I mean. Like in the end, I want to imagine that James Somerton doesn't harbor any resentment or hate towards HBomberGuy because I feel like they both want the same thing. They both want to write awesome content and great video essays about interesting things. Overall, I hope James turns it around.

Yeah, exactly. I don't think I have the answer to that. I mean, I am not even saying it was the wrong way. I just don't feel good about the way taken and I am wondering if there was a better way. That said, something needed to be done and the result is good it seems but it's important to remember everyone is human. Everyone has a soul. Everyone's soul is immeasurably valuable.

I'm not saying that at all. I'm just saying I can't feel good about the video. In fact, I covered this in my original comment. It needed to be done in some way but I am not sure it's the right way.