It's not that one

Your guess was done by a solo artist, the song I used wasn't

It's not that song

This song was by a one-hit wonder

Open Arms by Journey?

Not that one

This song's a quite a bit older

Not that one

Not that one

Good guess & good song, but it's not that one

The band's genre is heavy metal, alternative metal, nu metal, hard rock, or progressive metal (according to Wikipedia)

Look What The Cat Dragged In by Poison?

It's not that song, but that is totally what I would've guessed if I didn't know the answer

Correct! 🎉

Not that one, but a good guess