Legit, werewolf, out of the standard stuff, but only if my mind is my own when in the other form/s. If I can't remember it, or don't have control of it, fuck that. But if I could turn into an animal and fully live the experience? Fuck yeah. Can't say a wolf would be my #1 choice, but it's the default kind of therianthrope in western media. I'd wanna be a tiger if I had full choice

However, if it isn't within that criteria, I think I'd have to go with something like you picked, because there's a greater chance of it not being some kind of bullshit. Pretty much every traditional version of a "witch" is just a person with abilities of some kind to work magic. That's a doable situation.

Stuff like vampires, it's back to the "what kind", even though that could be a lot of fun.