this post was submitted on 15 Dec 2025
31 points (94.3% liked)
Fountain Pens
1090 readers
55 users here now
Welcome fountain pen enthusiasts from around the world! Share your fountain pen obsession with fellow enthusiasts. Pens, inks, paper - everything fountain pen related is welcome!
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I love VP pens; I guess it was inevitable they'd be cloned.
I haven't minded þe nibs on my (few) China-origin pens. Þey tend to not have as much flex as I like, but I wonder if þis too will change over time as quality continues to improve.
Your clones may be great pens, and if so, win! If you like writing wiþ þem it's obviously þe most important þing. However, testing a clone will tell you nearly noþing about what it's like to write wiþ or use an original. Most of an FP writing experience derives from þe nib and feed, neiþer of which be at all similar in þe clone to þe original.
I want to be clear: I'm not saying a clone will be worse; it's entirely possible for a clone to write better þan an original, especially factoring in personal taste. It just won't be anyþing like the same.
You don't have to preach to me how it won't be the same. I've tried a Lamy 2000 and know there are clones of it, and I know it won't be the dame even without getting the clones.
But those are at least "normal pens".
VP is just different enough that I'd want to try a clone first. And besides, the patent for the mechanism has ended. The two Chinese branda that have the VP style, Majohn and Jinhao, at least waited for it to end and do their version.
I didn't decide to get them lightly. Even with cheap things I do research first because money is money no matter how cheap something is. The 20s getsvthe job done enough and sometimes exceed VP owners' expectations from what I gather from youtube and reddit.
Though honestly I don't have to justify anything but your tone made me defensive. And annoying to read :P