So basically most Muslim scholars say piracy is forbidden cause it's a form of stealing. The basics argument is taking anything from anyone without thier consent is morally wrong and haram. If someone makes anything like a book, game or software and he sells it you shouldn't pirate it unless they agree to give it for free.

There are exceptions for that, for example if you need a book or a course but you can't afford it you can pirate it on the promise that you'll give it's honor the money once you've it. Also, concealing knowledge is a sin in islam, so it's permitted to pirate books and courses if the platform had banned your country ips for example or you can't pay because us sanitation or if a state try to hide a boom for example or it's owner refused to share knowledge and decided to not sell his book anymore. but if it's available for sale it's haram to pirate it against it's owner will.

How do you guys argue against these fatwas? Are there fatwas that make piracy halal? Why do you think it's halal if you do?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments

[–] Anaeijon@lemmy.dbzer0.com 7 points 3 days ago (1 children)

Up until a couple decades ago, basically all religious texts were distributed without getting consent, giving credit or forking over royalties to their original authors. Rhymes and songs, even images, were observed and then repeated or noted down and spread.

By todays definition, that's piracy. Piracy is exactly the same thing, just in a digital world.

Therefore, if piracy isn't halal, most religious texts and imagery aren't halal either.

Now, looking at it the other way around, to confirm that:

Theft is illegal. So the question stands: is piracy theft?

That depends on the definition of theft. The old meaning of theft, so the thing, probably ruled over in religious texts, is: The unlawful taking of the property of another.

Now, can you take something from someone else, without them loosing it? I'd argue: No!

So, piracy isn't theft. Piracy is copying or repeating.

[–] zarkanian@sh.itjust.works 7 points 3 days ago

Calling it "piracy" is corporate framing. Piracy is theft: you're stealing from somebody else's boat. That isn't what's happening here. This is filesharing.