766
Story of Cruz
(lemmy.world)
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 29 Oct 2023
766 points (86.8% liked)
4chan
4208 readers
4 users here now
Greentexts, memes, everything 4chan.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
There are also millions of people with intellectual challenges and horrid childhoods who do NOT go out and murder people.
People react differently to being abused by people and society for years and years, until they have every last ounce of hope drained from them.
Yes but it doesn't mean it's excusable or justifiable to murder innocent people.
Damn another strawman! He didn't say "ehh let's forgive him, he had it rough". It's just an explanation for why it probably happened.
They claim it's 100% societies fault. So even while trying to defend they remove all agency from this guy. Yes, let's work to improve systems to give everyone a better shake, but don't discard his own horrible actions.
Post itself sugests it's society fault not his as if making him innocent. If someone is strawman it is you for picking things out of context.
He is morally innocent though which is the point, even if he's criminally guilty. The strawman is hearing "we can't be surprised and we can still feel bad for him" and equating that to saying "he should be let go!". He can still be guilty for his actions even though it's almost entirely society's fault.
No he's not, because once again the vast majority of people who have bad childhoods and mental challenges don;t go murdering people. He is in no way morally innocent.
The fact that anybody thinks otherwise is really suspicious. Some dudes in suits are going to start monitoring this thread.
Nobody is justifying anything. If we want to stop these things from happening we need to actually understand why they happen.
Post itself suggests its somehow excusable I disagree.
To me makes sense to stea money but to kill other just for sake of killing them is closer to serial killer thinking than desperation .
No the deciding factor is to decide at some point that others are supposedly at fault for your problems and that they deserve to be hurt for it.
So you're saying it's his fault his mother drank and that he was abused by his foster parents?
???
It's his fault that he killed people.
Because of his problems, that largely weren't his fault.
Your mental health issues are never your fault - but always your responsibility.
As stated in the greentext, his problems were society's fault. He was responsible for the consequences of his actions though.
I think @ParsnipWitch@feddit.de want to say that those murdered people were thought by the killer to be at fault for killer's problems they had nothing to do with.
What do you think is the difference between people who decide to hurt and murder others and those who don't?
I'm not an authority on criminal psychology. You should look on Google Scholar.
100% this is such a bad strawman.