I think I'm missing something from your perspective here? The idea in this image only works with the players consent at the first step of the process? If the player wants to nix it, they have the chance to do so before it's ever used in game.

I saw this meme, and thought it sounded great, so if I were going to bring it to my table, it would have been pretty much exactly in the form I read here.

How would you suggest that a GM approaches it to get player consent that is different to how it's laid out here?