I could never wrap my head around the discoverability and reach issues -- I haven't had any problems with either of those, and I'm running a solo server (though I've come to suspect that there was maybe a jargon and expectation barrier, and they just couldn't overcome the different layout).

What I can understand is running away from the somewhat, uh, hostile welcome many of them got. Instead of bringing people in and helping them acclimate, a bunch of folks just got up in new peoples' faces and gave them no room to make faux pas.

I don't see that happening here. The crowd that's showed up over the last week or so has been made up of core Reddit folks, and the atmosphere is very Reddit in nature.

It's just the volume of content that is missing, and that already feels like it's inching toward critical mass and can become self-sustaining.