this post was submitted on 15 May 2026
15 points (89.5% liked)
Funny
322 readers
73 users here now
Funniest content on all Lemmygrad
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I think that art requires suffering. If there was a way that could make an art piece without suffering and spending any time on it, it would be worthless
I'm not even talking about studying it, although it does also requires a lot of effort, but the process of making art, process of trying and trying again and again, making errors, fixing them, making more errors, until it's something you at least fine with it. It applies not only for drawing, but for every artistic expression I think that if we remove that part from the process of creating art, we strip it of any worth. That's why hand-made stuff is still relevant, hand-made mug might be worth more for you because you made it, or someone you love made it, or you just bought it from some weird funny looking guy who makes mugs and sell it for overprice, even though there's factory made objectively better mugs for objectively better price. So, maybe AI does the same thing as human brain but faster, just like factory machines can do things better than humans. But the time, effort, the suffering of making something is what gives art any value in my opinion. Just like, well, any kind of work requires effort, but if in production faster and cheaper is desired thing, art has different goals, I think that human effort to just make pretty picture or depict your idea is more desiarable than whatever AI might provide with art. Although I do agree that if your goal is to depict your idea and you lack the skills required but you really want to, using AI is a way, especially if you lack time and/or will to commit to learning art, and you lack finances to commision artist. But if I see a painting I can be impressed with artist learning all the skills required, all the details or even lack of them, it is cool. If I see ai generated image the best I can say that it might be neat idea, I could not possible comment on execution, just like I couldn't comment on a factory made mug. (Well I could say that factory is cool thing too, and that AI can generate pictures is pretty cool too, I just can't agree that it can be considered art) In art, as I see it, the skill of the author is equally, if not more important than idea. Because whatever idea you might put in it, people will intrepret it however they see it unless you just spell it out and if you do what even the point
Sorry if it's a bit incoherent I'm also thinking while writing..
I mean that's where the whole term artisanal comes in. People place more value on things that were crafted by hand end to end as opposed to manufactured using an industrial process. That's why I don't really see image generation replacing traditional art. People still paint on canvas even though photoshop exists, and we tend to place more value on a physical painting than a digital one.
I'd argue AI generated content serves a different purpose from high art though, same way a mug made in a factory coexists with artisanal mugs you'd attach sentimental value to. For example, take the whole Iranian Lego videos that turned out to be extremely effective propaganda. Nobody would argue they're high art you'd display in a gallery, but they are effective, they evoke an emotional response, and they convey the message in a clever and creative way.
Before AI tools were available, the US effectively had a monopoly on such messaging because it was a highly labor intensive process that could only be accomplished by skilled 3d artists. It took a company the size of Pixar to produce something equivalent. But now, this process has been democratized, and a small studio in Iran can punch way above their weight to challenge imperial propaganda.
I think that's where the real value for this stuff comes in. Iran proved that we can use it for effective messaging. We can make memes and catchy short videos that promote our ideas and do it in a way that connects with people.