this post was submitted on 07 Dec 2025
9 points (90.9% liked)
College Football
976 readers
1 users here now
A community to discuss college football.
| /c/CFB Poll Top 25 |  |
|---|---|
| 1. Indiana |  |
| 2. Ohio State |  |
| 3. Texas A&M |  |
| 4. Alabama |  |
| ~~5. BYU~~ |  |
| 6. Ole Miss |  |
| 7. Georgia |  |
| 8. Texas Tech | |
| ~~9. Virginia~~ |  |
| T-10. Oregon |  |
| T-10. Texas |  |
| ~~T-12. Memphis~~ |  |
| T-12. Oklahoma |  |
| 14. Utah |  |
| T-15. Georgia Tech |  |
| T-15. Vanderbilt |  |
| T-15. North Texas |  |
| ~~T-18. Louisville~~ |  |
| T-18. South Florida |  |
| 20. Notre Dame |  |
| 21. USC |  |
| 22. Michigan |  |
| 23. Miami |  |
| T-24. Tennessee |  |
| ~~T-24. San Diego State~~ |  |
Check out our other sports communities!
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I don't have a problem with a single G5 team getting in. Especially if one goes undefeated, they deserve the opportunity. More than one is a farce though. The playoffs should be for teams that have a legitimate chance of winning.
Hard disagree with you on all counts. The playoff should not be limited to the top 12 teams with the best odds at winning it. If that is what we wanted, the games wouldn't matter. We would just use the Las Vegas odds to find the best teams. If the games matter, we need to value winning, and punish losing. The hard part is, although James Madison objectively has done more winning this year than every team other than Indiana, Texas Tech, Ohio State, and Georgia. The conflict comes from the fact that winning with James Madison's schedule is objectively easier than those other 4 schools. So how do we tell which team is better? Our current system allows us to see. Put James Madison up against Oregon, and let's see. That is what I'm excited to see.
We have a system. It's called strength of schedule. It's arguably not used enough. Notre Dame didn't deserve to be in because they lost the only games they played against good teams. Same with Tulane, they don't really deserve a spot either.
Personally I care more about quality wins than losses. I'd rather see a 3 loss Texas over a 2 loss Miami.
I don't have a problem with letting a single G5 team in, like I said above, but 2 is absurd. It's a playoff, it's meant to have the best teams.