this post was submitted on 02 Feb 2026
27 points (100.0% liked)

Thoughtful Discussion

383 readers
5 users here now

Welcome

Open discussions and thoughts. Make anything into a discussion!

Leaving a comment explaining why you found a link interesting is optional, but encouraged!

Rules

  1. Follow the rules of discuss.online
  2. No porn
  3. No self-promotion
  4. Don't downvote simply because you disagree or as a reaction to a title. Doing so may result in a temp community ban.

More posting guidelines can be found here:

https://discuss.online/post/33592245

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
 

An interesting keynote about hidden cost of AI Art by the author Brandon Sanderson. I might be a bit biased though, since Sanderson is my favourite author, and I am resistant to some of the things "AI" is used for, if not completely anti-AI.

What do you think about this?

Note: It's from the event in Dec 2025, it was just posted in text form recently. If you want to watch the video, you can do it here: https://youtu.be/RXyWtp8tuYY?t=1988 (about 15-20 mins long, might have to go couple of seconds forward or backward)

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] calliope@retrolemmy.com 1 points 1 day ago

but the questions "Why read another human's writing if an AI's is better?" still has no answer.

Of course it does. Because the human creator was affected while creating it. What you quoted explains the whole thing.

Well, remember, art is not just the story. It is not just the painting or the sculpture or whatever else you love to create. It’s also the process of creation and what that process does to you. We make art because we can’t help it. It’s part of us.

I added bold because that’s the core point. Of course I would rather read something where a human was affected by the process of creating. That’s relatable, and the entire purpose of art.

You read another human’s writing because they’re human, and a human who experienced something while creating is unquestionably superior to what amounts to randomness. An LLM can’t think, learn, or have human-like experiences. It can only copy. Expression is the important thing, and an LLM can’t express.

AI can’t compete with a human’s passion or interest, and doing something with passion or interest is what makes something art.

The act of creation by a human literally makes all the difference.