I see you haven't been introduced to Yahtzee Croshaw and his Zero Punctuation series. Also, Steam reviews are full of bots.

I haven't followed professional outlets for a long time. It's pretty obvious most of them do not have enough time to give a proper review to these massive, 120+ hour long games. I used to read Computer Gaming World. Their reviewers would often mention that their rules required them to complete the game. Most of the reviews I see today, they don't even necessarily get the whole fuckin' game in their review copy. Just look at BG3.

Phenomenal game, with a solid story, incredible characters, fun game play, and just... Bugs. Lotta bugs. Especially after the first act. You might not even realize you are getting them because so many are that things that should happen, don't. The reviews for it clearly only covered the first, most polished act. And even then, they didn't actually mention bugs there and while it's the most polished, it is still far from perfect. As time goes on and more people push further into the game, now those same review outlets put out editorials reporting on players bitching about the bugs on social media. Things that should have been covered in their own official reviews in the first damn place.

If all they're going to do is write a bunch of bullshit they were likely paid to say, and then rely on users to generate more "news" content for them, I'm just going to stick with going straight to other players. There are still plenty that think for themselves and give honest, detailed descriptions of the game while trying to limit their personal opinions and bias. I want to be told how the thing actually is and make my own mind up based on my opinions; reviews can be objective.