Improper paperwork could be "I did what one border guard said but then the next time I crossed a different border guard said the rules were different". Maybe that woman fucked up but given that she was dealing with those fucking idiots at the border, I'm giving her the benefit of the doubt
canada
Canada is not the US's hat. The US is Canada's pants.
Riddle me this: there is a door with a 1/1000th chance that if you enter through you will end up in an El Salvador gulag. Do you open it?
Only cross into the US through a "preclearance" checkpoint from now on. I.e. an airport/train station/etc. where US CBP officers are working deep in the foreign country and processing your visa BEFORE you even step onto the airplane/train. If you get denied, you'll probably just get denied boarding on the plane since you're not even in the US at all, and you can just go straight home
Much less risk of getting detained by US CBP like that Vancouver woman who got denied at the Vancouver airport, then flew to Mexico and then got denied entry into the USA after that and detained
I entered the US recently at a preclearance airport and I had no issues. Face piercings, tattoos, work visa expiring in a few months, POC and had no issues
I'd never try to enter the US from now on where I have to get my visa approved either at a land border or inside the actual country after landing
What about leaving the US? Do they detain people on the way out?
I've never had to deal with any customs officers when leaving the country, even as a non citizen
I've once once or twice seen US officials stopping people at a US -> Canada land crossing, to check IDs. Maybe checking for outstanding warrants or something, it wasn't clear. That was I think under Obama, definitely not recent, and I've only seen it a couple times. Just pointing out that it is technically possible.
I would be more concerned about tracking by license plates and cell phones, anywhere near a border.
Ah true I should've mentioned I only ever leave/enter the US by airplane. On purpose because I've heard all sorts of terrible things about the land border both international and interstate
TSA seems way better than the land border officers from what I've heard about them
I recently crossed at Pearson, and it was very much not out of the ordinary. I said why I was visiting, where I was staying and when I was flying back, they didn’t ask for documentation, didn’t check my phone. May be different when crossing a land border tho, I assume the border agents who are based out of Toronto/Vancouver/Montreal are more chill than the ones based out of a US city.