37
submitted 1 year ago by NorskSud@lemmy.pt to c/europe@feddit.de

Jewish organisations said the vandalism was 'horrifying' and 'shameful'

top 23 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[-] randomname01@feddit.nl 21 points 1 year ago

While this is unacceptable, I do think it’s curious that a lot of the news coverage about the riots in France has been about those relatively small stories where the rioters look to be completely in the wrong.

These riots are the product of understandable and logical frustrations with French police (and local police more broadly, looking at riots in Brussels), yet most news stories about it are things like this or almost non stories about the rioters also being aggressive towards journalists.

Is vandalism of holocaust memorials acceptable? No. Should fringe stories like that be the focus of riots that are fundamentally about something completely different? No as well, in my opinion. And I’m kind of wary that it does seem like the coverage is going to unfold like that.

[-] NorskSud@lemmy.pt 3 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago)

But what else is there? The riots are violent by nature, these are not peaceful demonstrations. And incidents like this show how violence goes in the worst directions. That these riots spread to Brussels is even more absurd.

I'm all for people protesting and defending an political position, violence might even be excused or justified. But this "spontaneous" riots, this n'importe quoi violence is a disaster, there's no agenda, no strategy, no nothing and in the end Le Pen will be the one pocketing gains from this. This is really a disaster and police violence will only more likely increase.

PS: In Metz a library was burnt down to the ground, these are very stupid levels of violence.

[-] randomname01@feddit.nl 9 points 1 year ago

That these riots spread to Brussels is even more absurd

No it’s not. The police in Brussels have long had problems with racism in their ranks (and the behaviour that comes with that), so it makes a lot of sense that this struck a nerve with a lot of people in Brussels

Also, on the riots having no direction or clear goal: fucking duh, they’re riots. But as MLK put it: “A riot is the language of the unheard.” These communities often have to take it on the chin until it reaches a breaking point, and then stuff like this happens. Does that mean it’s entirely excusable? Not necessarily. But it does mean you’re missing the point when spouting platitudes about this not being the most effective method of activism. You’re complaining that boiling water can’t properly canalise itself, because you’re imagining that’s what you would do in all your wisdom.

[-] NorskSud@lemmy.pt -1 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago)

I don't think it is a platitude to expect people to act in a rational and non violent way (I actually consider that to be the bare minimum expected from anyone). This is irrational violence and it's inexcusable (your platitudes do not excuse it) and the result is simple, political forces promising more power to the police will become stronger because most people don't buy those platitudes of yours nor this absurd violence that destroys monuments in honor of Shoa victims or entire libraries.

[-] randomname01@feddit.nl 3 points 1 year ago

…of course it’s not the politically optimal move, but it’s still understandable. You just sound like a sheltered wanker who’s trying his best to deliberately not understand how riots come to be so you can completely dismiss where the rioters are coming from.

[-] NorskSud@lemmy.pt -3 points 1 year ago

Oh right, according to you they're coming from the segregated communities of southern US in the 60s, wasn't it that your totally not abusive comparison?

I think the one who sounds like a sheltered/spoiled guy here it's you. Clearly you don't fear being a direct or indirect victim of these riots. I fear both.

[-] randomname01@feddit.nl 1 points 1 year ago

according to you they’re coming from the segregated communities of southern US in the 60s, wasn’t it that your totally not abusive comparison

What the fuck are you on about? You have to be being dense on purpose now.

[-] NorskSud@lemmy.pt -2 points 1 year ago

Says the guy that called me a wanker from the confort of his shelter

[-] randomname01@feddit.nl 1 points 1 year ago

What does that have to do with anything?

[-] NorskSud@lemmy.pt -2 points 1 year ago

It wasn't me personalizing the debate. But since we're there I do fear being a victim of this violence, as I live in one of the cities affected by it, and I do fear the right wing turn this will provoke. People like you, comfortably justifying this nonsense from their sofa, are part of the problem and I'm quite sure you're not personally worried with a far right government coming to power. You should be though.

[-] randomname01@feddit.nl 2 points 1 year ago

I understand you’re afraid to be a victim of this violence. I still disagree with your takes here, and you clearly aren’t arguing in good faith.

People like you, comfortably justifying this nonsense

I explicitly said it wasn’t necessarily justified, but that it was understandable and logical nonetheless.

I’m quite sure you’re not personally worried with a far right government coming to power

I very much am. But it’s possible to simultaneously be worried about how right wingers will twist this while also acknowledging this reaction makes sense looking at the bigger picture.

[-] NorskSud@lemmy.pt 0 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago)

This reaction does not make sense if the goal is social peace, I don't believe these rioters want social peace. They want unrest and they're achieving their goal. It's short sighted, but it's what it is. And then some lefties uncapable of emptying the tires of an SUV (a valid direct action) get all "I undertsand" this pointless violence because of "reasons". And then you wonder why left wing voters turn to the right.

Most people in the suburbs do not participate in these riots, they fear them, this only decreases the life quality of such places etc etc "understanding" won't help stop them, but it's the reason why so many people from minority backgrounds end up voting for Le Pen, because they're fed up of living like this.

[-] randomname01@feddit.nl 2 points 1 year ago

Yeah congratulations, this isn’t a well organised social movement. It’s ab outburst of years of pent up frustration. They’re not trying to achieve any specific goals here. Yet again, you fundamentally misunderstand what riots are about and then condescendingly whine that it’s not a focused effort at bringing about societal change - while that’s not what it was from the start. You keep droning on about long term goals, but you just don’t understand that this is an outburst after years of taking it on the chin.

It’s like someone who’s been mistreated by their partner for year, and who now lashes out and starts kicking and screaming - meanwhile you’re on the sidelines saying that they should engage in a constructive dialogue. Ok cool, that would be nice in an ideal world, but that wasn’t going to happen here.

this pointless violence because of “reasons”

Ah dope, you’re clearly trying to understand the background here.

And then you wonder why left wing voters turn to the right.

Nah, I understand perfectly well why people turn to right wingers. They’re unburdened by the need for truth, so they can twist this into whatever populist narrative they like. Add onto that that a whole lot of leftists are actually spineless neolibs who wear red, and there you are. However, what you’re implying here is problematic. Either I should completely agree with your take (which is funnily largely in line with what liberals (not leftists) would say, or in aiding and abetting the far right. Yeah ok lmao.

but it’s the reason why so many people from minority backgrounds end up voting for Le Pen, because they’re fed up of living like this.

Correct, this is a product of liberals pretending they care about everyone while not wanting to change the status quo, thereby keeping minorities under their heel. When this (inevitably) goes awry, right wing reactionaries are there to capitalise on that inherent hypocrisy. However, that does not mean we shouldn’t try to understand how this came to be, and that we shouldn’t be empathetic. Otherising minorities and bending over backward to not understand their motivations and frustrations (like you’re doing) is exactly what right wingers want and do.

And yet again, I want to emphasise that I don’t like this violence, it won’t lead to change, and reactionaries will use it to their advantage. All of that’s sad to tragic, but that doesn’t mean these riots aren’t understandable. And that’s what you’re missing; you recognise it won’t do too much to help their cause, and because of that you dismiss everything about it entirely. That’s why you can’t possibly fathom why people in Brussels are rioting as well. That’s why you bang on about it not being effective activism. It’s because you fundamentally don’t seem to (want to) understand how and why riots and social unrest come to be.

[-] NorskSud@lemmy.pt -1 points 1 year ago

Those comparisons of yours are really unfortunate. No, this is not comparable to the woman abused by the husband. This is not an individual story. And the reason why it spreads to Brussels but not Amsterdam or Madrid is culture. Culture, not just language and definetely not the level of police abuse. And this culture of violence should not be understood but fought.

[-] randomname01@feddit.nl 2 points 1 year ago

It was an analogy in a vain attempt to make you understand how lashing out works, and how your condescending and paternalistic attitude is absurd - but I should’ve known you’re too thick-skulled to even try to get it.

And yeah wow, social movements spread faster when people have more in common? Thanks for the insight, fam. Like yeah, that’s god damn obvious and I’m not sure why you think this is some sort of gotcha. It hit home for so many people in Brussels because they share a lot of the same problems, while having the same cultural background and speaking the same languages. You’re so close to getting why these riots spread to Brussels, but above all you just want to be mad about the violence.

I understand your frustration with and anxiety about these riots, but you’re letting those feelings keep you from grappling with the how and the why of these riots. Unless you try to show some understanding, I see no reason to continue this conversation.

[-] NorskSud@lemmy.pt 1 points 1 year ago

Seriously dude read your own comments, read your tone and then think again who's being "condescending and paternalistic" ffs. You believe so much in your moral superiority that you don't even see it, do you? Jeez, that's the level of lunacy..

[-] randomname01@feddit.nl 2 points 1 year ago

Also, something I forgot to add; Le Pen and co will make up a narrative regardless of the situation. “They’ll use this to their advantage” isn’t really a convincing point, because if nothing real is happening they’ll just make something up. What’s more, the narrative they spin about this will mostly be lies anyway, as it always is.

[-] NorskSud@lemmy.pt -1 points 1 year ago

Point being, this is not made up, this is reality. People are wishing for order and police in their street right now. Whoever delivers it wins, it might even be Macron's party.. but definetely not the left that "understands". Because the people stuck in their apartment all weekend or with their bicycle or car stolen or burnt is not understanding the impunity of these tugs.

[-] randomname01@feddit.nl 2 points 1 year ago

Their narrative about this will largely be made up, using these riots to pretend that people with foreign backgrounds are dangerous savages or something like that. They always take something that really happened and twist it into something it’s not.

Therefore, it makes no sense to change your opinion or interpretation of a situation based on how the right wing will use it to spin a narrative. There’s always something they can be mad about, and they’ll always pretend it’s worse than it actually is.

[-] NorskSud@lemmy.pt 1 points 1 year ago

The situation is burning libraries, cars, bus, bicycles.

That's the situation and that's what people want to be over as soon as possible. The people in the bad suburbs and the people downtown, the ones suffering with this.

[-] randomname01@feddit.nl 2 points 1 year ago

That these riots spread to Brussels is even more absurd

No it’s not. The police in Brussels have long had problems with racism in their ranks (and the behaviour that comes with that), so it makes a lot of sense that this struck a nerve with a lot of people in Brussels

Also, on the riots having no direction or clear goal: fucking duh, they’re riots. But as MLK put it: “A riot is the language of the unheard.” These communities often have to take it on the chin until it reaches a breaking point, and then stuff like this happens. Does that mean it’s entirely excusable? Not necessarily. But it does mean you’re missing the point when spouting platitudes about this not being the most effective method of activism. You’re complaining that boiling water can’t properly canalise itself, because you’re imagining that’s what you would do in all your wisdom.

[-] randomname01@feddit.nl 0 points 1 year ago

That these riots spread to Brussels is even more absurd

No it’s not. The police in Brussels have long had problems with racism in their ranks (and the behaviour that comes with that), so it makes a lot of sense that this struck a nerve with a lot of people in Brussels

Also, on the riots having no direction or clear goal: fucking duh, they’re riots. But as MLK put it: “A riot is the language of the unheard.” These communities often have to take it on the chin until it reaches a breaking point, and then stuff like this happens. Does that mean it’s entirely excusable? Not necessarily. But it does mean you’re missing the point when spouting platitudes about this not being the most effective method of activism. You’re complaining that boiling water can’t properly canalise itself, because you’re imagining that’s what you would do in all your wisdom.

load more comments
view more: next ›
this post was submitted on 01 Jul 2023
37 points (91.1% liked)

Europe

8324 readers
4 users here now

News/Interesting Stories/Beautiful Pictures from Europe 🇪🇺

(Current banner: Thunder mountain, Germany, 🇩🇪 ) Feel free to post submissions for banner pictures

Rules

(This list is obviously incomplete, but it will get expanded when necessary)

  1. Be nice to each other (e.g. No direct insults against each other);
  2. No racism, antisemitism, dehumanisation of minorities or glorification of National Socialism allowed;
  3. No posts linking to mis-information funded by foreign states or billionaires.

Also check out !yurop@lemm.ee

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS