American born to English ex-pats here. We also left out beer for Santa - and carrots for the reindeer.
We left cookies out too, I'll have to ask if the cookies (and maybe the carrots too) were just put back in the box/fridge, or what actually got eaten.
Edit: my dad says the beer and cookies were definitely eaten but "neither of those pair well with carrots" so apparently they just went back in the fridge. I'm not sure why my brother and I bothered with the carrots then π
π€π€π€