Penny in Pokemon Scarlet/Violet:
- Is a shy, introverted hacker girl with a big hoodie:
-
Her ace Pokemon is a Sylveon, which has been adopted by the trans community as an icon because of its trans pride color palette
-
When she terastallizes her Sylveon, she says "Shine bright like the starry sky and become who you really want to be!"
She is also the leader and "founder" of Team Star, a group of kids who got united after being bullied at school. Though this could also fit a non-conforming cis girl, it would fit a trans girl especially well.
I'm still not convinced on whether it's a crazy series of coincidences or not. If I had to guess, the developers knew exactly what they were doing and created a trans character that the intended audience would recognize as such, but bigots and Nintendo executives wouldn't. The line "become who you really want to be" is just too specific, no other character says anything like that when they terastallize their Pokemon.
Pokemon has never really had openly LGBT characters so I have to imagine that if it was intentional, it was snuck by executives. Penny does not meet the mainstream media's idea of a stereotypical trans woman, but she does meet a lot of stereotypes within the trans community itself that most cis people wouldn't be aware of. Like I said, I'm honestly still not 100% certain that it's not a coincidence, but I do think she's effectively a dogwhistle character. Also her theme goes way too hard.
What do you guys think?
Sidenote: In terms of characters and story Scarlet and Violet are so far ahead of other mainline Pokemon games, it really is not close. Team Star are a group of real characters with real, relatable motivations and goals, not a group of cartoonish goons who want to dry the oceans for some nauseating reason. Arven's story with his Mabosstiff is so grounded but so effective as well. The climax of the game is actually climactic and emotionally impactful, it's not just "the legendary pokemon from the cover appears". The Elite 4 are real characters who live in the region and interact with you and each other instead of just being overdesigned randos who you fight at the end and never think about again. The story twist with the professor is pretty much unprecedented in Pokemon games.
I don't wanna defend Nintendo's business practices because them rushing it out is the reason the game runs like ass, in terms of performance it's the worst one they ever made. But creatively, Scarlet and Violet are leagues above anything the main series has ever put out. No Pokemon game has ever changed up the formula to this extent and like I said, the story is better than all other games combined. That's why it kinda bothers me when people say they "aren't trying anymore" because the people actually making the game clearly were trying.