this post was submitted on 13 Nov 2025
4 points (83.3% liked)
Woodworking
566 readers
1 users here now
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Definitely paint it. Purists will hate paint. But there's a reason we cover our houses in paint and not stain or varnish. Your tray has a base made of OSB; this isn't a project where showing off the grain matters. I would put a coat of oil based primer and two or three coats of oil based enamel paint.
I do like the idea of it draining into a plastic container. But ultimately, if you put thick paint on it, you are essentially creating a plastic container.
110% correct... It's in the garage where nobody goes to boot so even if I wanted pretty, nobody would see it... I swear if I fall and get hurt there I would die of starvation before anyone in my fam discovers we have a garage hahaha
Thanks for your feedback
Yeah, the woodworking community tends to loathe paint, for obvious reasons. There's no point in working hard and making something nice out of high quality hardwood if you're just going to paint over it. Which is where the opposition to paint comes from. I share that sentiment for projects where it matters. I wouldn't make a desk out of black walnut and then paint it. But anything made of OSB? That's a material you choose when you just want strength and function and aesthetics are irrelevant. And if looks don't matter, and it needs to be waterproof, paint is the way to go.
110% agree!