205
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 04 Sep 2023
205 points (97.2% liked)
Baldur's Gate 3
6322 readers
6 users here now
All things BG3!
Baldur’s Gate 3 is a story-rich, party-based RPG set in the universe of Dungeons & Dragons, where your choices shape a tale of fellowship and betrayal, survival and sacrifice, and the lure of absolute power. (Website)
Spoilers
If your post contains any possible spoilers, please:
- Use the text [SPOILER] at the beginning of your title, do not include any spoilers in the title.
- Use the appropriate spoiler markup to conceal that content in the body of your post.
Thank you!
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
I'm just really not a fan over how heavy RNG it is. I have to save scum like crazy.
It's... it's based on DnD, a game reliant on dice rolls. The core of it is the RNG that changes the probability of every encounter. I'll never understand people who keep saying the thing they hate about BG3 is always a core DnD mechanic when Larian has only every been upfront about this being them using 5e as their base to build the game around. This is the closest to a single player TTRPG simulator that we've ever had. What kind of game were you expecting?
I think lots of people didn’t know what kind of game they were expecting. Some people bought the game because it was popular, rather than because they necessarily like the genre.
I’m not a DnD fan (tried playing a few times, just never clicked) and I find that the same things that I disliked about it are also the things I dislike about BG3.
That’s not to say it’s a bad game, and I’m enjoying it quite a bit, but there’s definitely elements of DnD that I feel are very limiting to the enjoyment of playing.
I'm very aware of all of that. I still don't like the heavy RNG lol. I want to save scum less, that's what I'm expecting. Even if it's 5e combat. I'm just not a fan of DnD combat, but I still love everything else about bg3.
In combat, I used to hate the fact that I miss very frequently but I realized enemies miss as much as I do. It changed my perspective - I strategize my game plan assuming I would miss rather than assuming I would hit. It improved my game a lot since.
It helps a lot when you start using abilities that gives you advantage, or that deal half damage even when they are saved against.
Of course, it's still a matter of preference. It's just how the game is, I guess.
Not a fan... not the game for you cupcake. Ruin some other game and leave ours the fuck alone.
Uh, no. My opinion is as valid as yours. How incredibly pretentious. I'm not required to like the combat system to enjoy a story game.
It's amazing how stupid some people are. You miss out on some amazing story and interaction by failing some rolls. Just like real D&D.
In fact, you can also miss out on some amazing story and interaction by succeeding rolls. Just like real D&D.
One of the things that's so impressive about this game is how well it handles and reacts to the variety of different decisions, succeeses, and failures you can make. Failing a roll in one spot likely just puts you on a different path, with a slightly different story.
In fact, particularly in narrative focused games, failure is just as important, if not moreso than success. How interesting is a story, really, if the characters never stumble or face hardship? It's not nearly as compelling if they succeed at every turn.
Even combat, having to flee with half your party dead is peak DnD. At least in BG3 you can easily revive them.
Might not be the game for you. Part of the appeal of dnd for me is not being to get everything because of the dice. Not every door can be unlocked, not every social interaction will succeed. Even combat, I have to flee with half the party dead and then revive them later because a critical spell didn't succeed or a concentration save wasn't made.
Yeah well when I do three 1/20 on a row when using inspirations dice on a roll your character should be a pro at it's... Frustrating.
Do you have Karmic Dice turned off, to get three crit fails in a row?
it's definitely not for everyone, I do a lot of save scumming as well, but mostly because I want it to play out how I want for the first playthrough and in a sense, make things easier while I still get used to mechanics. it's worth nothing that in a lot of dialog, a fail in a roll doesn't necessarily mean that you fail the dialog.
I'm sure eventually when Larian adds more modding capabilities like they plan to, there might be a mod or even a feature to turn off dice rolls
Sounds like you need to learn to play.