more evidence for the "Russia has been warning NATO about their red lines for two decades" pile
History
This is the general history subcom. Anything relating to history is welcome here. Doesn't have to be Marxist, though it certainly can be. So join in on the discussion and let's learn more.
Holy shit. This is like reading the fucking last entries of the diary ofna dead person. The west spiraling the world towards total war again.
I mean it just shows that the Russians have been saying the exact same things to the Americans for literally decades.
Very common sense things: don't expand NATO to Ukraine, don't demand things from us that you are not prepared to do yourselves, don't get any ideas about using nuclear weapons, don't break the balance of power that guarantees peace in the world, don't force us to start another arms race.
And back then even the uber-neocon Bush administration agreed with most of this. Now European politicians and the mainstream media tell us that Russia just came up with these things to justify their "aggression", or that they are totally unreasonable demands, or that they are threatening us, etc. etc.
These so-called "verbatim" memoranda add further indication onto the pile that the West fundamentally doesn't respect Russia through the entire post-Cold War period and why should they? The USSR was locked in a near half-century confrontation with the West. The inevitable battle lines were expected for decades to cut through the middle of Germany and then suddenly, without any concessions or sacrifice whatsoever, socialist Europe collapsed through Gorbachev's actions and the frontier of NATO moved from central Europe into the USSR itself.
As Putin puts it, "Soviet power changed the world, voluntarily. And Russians gave up thousands of square kilometers of territory, voluntarily. Unheard of. Ukraine, part of Russia for centuries, given away. Kazakhstan, given away. The Caucasus, too. Hard to imagine, and done by party bosses."
But the truth is that of Mao's: political power grows from the barrel of a gun. You have nothing if you gave away the gun. The West knows exactly what Russia sacrificed, and the unspoken reality whenever they hear Putin bring this up is that they couldn’t be happier with what Russia did. Because now, rather than fighting it out in West Berlin, the West gets to pitch the two largest former SSRs against each other. Even the junior partners of the first Cold War are validated in their vassalage because the battlefields are now safely far away from even these original sacrificial pawns.
Why would anyone bargain or cooperate with an adversary that might get hijacked by a comprador and give away the whole house to you without having to negotiate anything in return, so long as you be patient and wait? This has been the operating geopolitical mentality of the West since the Cold War, which is to say that they only have to squeeze their eyes shut and hold out for the escalating nightmare to end. This is the true psychological source of all those endless "[insert adversary here] collapse" fantasies and makes the West incapable of respecting or acknowledging any contemporary counterparts.
You can see Putin begging to join the West without Russia being reduced to a junior US partner. In response to Bush stating (both amusingly underestimating the speed of change and also echoing the current Trump rhetoric about Russia): "Russia belongs to the West; it is not an enemy. In 50 years, China could become a big problem. Russia's interests lie with the West. And you should be like the West," Putin apparently cautioned (which has now completely come to pass): "What you said about 50 years in the future is important. Russia is European and multi-ethnic, like the United States. I can imagine us becoming allies. Only dire need could make us allied with others. But we feel left out of NATO."
That's a very good explanation of the West's imperial hubris. What they fail to see is that the world has changed, the balance of power has fundamentally shifted and what worked 40 years ago just does not work anymore today. Their arrogance is proving to be their downfall.
Oohwee, I'm not going through all the docs right now, but I read some. I will say it again, Putin is extremely pragmatic. Do you know if these docs expound on his renouncing communism?

Hi thanks, I saw that, I didn't see his reasons for changing his mind.
Not sure on that part actually, there are a lot of them and haven't gone through most yet. :)
Yup, I have a podcast on, and thought I'd browse through them at leisure, but I'm still here because apparently, Comrade Yoggie is on a role! 🤣
Role? Roll*!
🤣


