this post was submitted on 07 Mar 2026
20 points (95.5% liked)

Ask Lemmygrad

1266 readers
37 users here now

A place to ask questions of Lemmygrad's best and brightest

founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
 

I have been reading a lot more recently with the goal of expanding my understanding of socialism, imperialism, and history from a socialist perspective. I have noticed two issues with my current routine: retention and motivation. I think that both of these could be improved by an opportunity to share and discuss with other people with similar interests, and I believe that other people may be going through the same struggle.

For this reason, I want to start a socialist reading circle and I was wondering if any friendly comrades have advice for successfully establishing one.

Some key issues:

  • Framing: I will be posting an ad for the event to a public group for English speakers (I'm a beginner in the local language) in the city I live in and I would like to be strategically inclusive to entice people who might be less politically conscious. Would "socialist reading circle" be the best or would a different framing be better?
  • Location: I would like to keep the circle out of the pub, but a weekday evening seems like the best time for a regular event like this. I was thinking that some sort of cafe might be the best option, but I would appreciate any suggestions.

I would appreciate any suggestions and experience from the community, so please don't hesitate to leave a comment.

all 9 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] Богданова@lemmygrad.ml 7 points 6 days ago (1 children)

Could I ask what are the long, medium and short term goals for the group you're trying to organize?

Did you already identify key contradictions playing out in your community and are interested in trying to solve them? Or is this more like a group of people who think Lenin and the like were badass?

lack of discipline and being unmotivated sounds like lack of confidence issues or maybe hopelessness, loneliness etc. Honestly and this might sound silly, but you should really consider including simple activities like finding interesting places around the city based on pictures provided and ik there's a name for it, but I have never played it so I forgot, but a lot of shy people are extremely self-cautious and group walks with a goal can ease them in much better than awkwardly sitting around in a claustrophobic room.

You could even do a socialist theme around it, like imagine how cool it'd be to go on a hike and learn about Mao's long march f.ex At least I'd be willing to do that with you. In between the events there's analysis and theory hours. I'm not exactly sure why i haven't thought of this before, but I'm writing this down in my notes lol

[–] flanzu@lemmygrad.ml 8 points 6 days ago (1 children)

Could I ask what are the long, medium and short term goals for the group you’re trying to organize?

For now, just to find like-minded people and even just see if there is any interest. I admit I haven't thought of long term goals, because I'm not sure if anyone will show up and if they do, what kind of people they will be.

Did you already identify key contradictions playing out in your community and are interested in trying to solve them?

I am an immigrant, so the main goal is to create some community and I think a community centred around reading and the desire to share and discuss is exactly what I want.

Well you could make a Migrant Socialist group for English speakers, but that sounds awful lot like Settler Socialism that someone is doing because they don't want to integrate with local communities and instead want to make one that suits them better, but you're probably not doing that I'm just saying how this comes across to locals and how they might get pretty pissed at you, especially if they're doing back breaking labor while the socialists are reading books, you'd probably have more luck with like an MTG group or Marvel fanclub.

[–] kromida@lemmygrad.ml 5 points 6 days ago (2 children)

Might be better to do it in the native language, if you speak it. The goal is local organizing afterall, so why in English?

[–] flanzu@lemmygrad.ml 7 points 6 days ago (1 children)

Unfortunately, I'm still a beginner in the local language... but the city is relatively international and many locals are part of the group.

[–] Commiejones@lemmygrad.ml 6 points 6 days ago

Maybe make it a Bilingual reading group? You get practice in the language and let locals practice their English while discussing the book. Might make it easier to find people because they might come primaily for the chance to practice english.

[–] Maeve@lemmygrad.ml 4 points 5 days ago

I'd be extremely interested in something like this. Maybe "socialist" would turn off propagandized people. Would something like "working class issues reading and activity group" work? Activity for the walking tour idea mentioned. Also maybe mutual aid, later, like meal or nonperishable foods distribution, if enough interest is shown.

[–] Alaskaball@hexbear.net 2 points 6 days ago

If you're going to be publicly reading the book at the meeting instead of saying 'read X chapter before the meeting' have a format where you read for X amount of minutes then break for a discussion period for X amount of minutes, where you alternate between reading and discussing until the end of the session. To make sure discussions don't get out of hand, follow a loose sort of roberts rules for meetings where you have a speakers list that allots like 1-2 minutes of speaking time per person with new people having priority and repeat speakers being sent to the bottom of the list every time they raise their hand.

So like initially if we're having a discussion where I raise my hand, jimbo raises his hand, Octavia raises her hand, Josh raises his hand, Jessica raises her hand, and Trotters raises his hand, the speaking list would be as follows

  1. Alaskaball
  2. Jimbo
  3. Octavia
  4. Josh
  5. Jessica
  6. Trotters

And let's say that by the time we reached Josh, I want to speak again because someone said something that inspires me to add to it BUT another person who hadn't spoken, Kiara and José, both raise their hands at the same time. The list would look like as follows

  1. ~~Alaskaball~~
  2. ~~Jimbo~~
  3. ~~Octavia~~
  4. Josh
  5. Jessica
  6. Trotters
  7. Kiara
  8. José
  9. Alaskaball

Make sure you keep track of the allotted time for discussion periods to make sure you don't burn your reading time by being firm with saying who's going to be the last speaker for this round but you'll keep the list of speakers who didn't speak so the next round they can go first if they wish to.

This communal reading and discussing style can seem slower for the more book savvy and intelligentsia types but public reading discussions definitely helps build a common foundation of theoretical literacy for the group as a whole.