101

Results of the "Can you tell which images are AI generated?" survey (i.vgy.me)

submitted 11 months ago by SwingingKoala@discuss.tchncs.de to c/imageai@sh.itjust.works

9 comments fedilink hide all child comments

cross-posted from: https://programming.dev/post/4070845

Previous posts: https://programming.dev/post/3974121 and https://programming.dev/post/3974080

Original survey link: https://forms.gle/7Bu3Tyi5fufmY8Vc8

Thanks for all the answers, here are the results for the survey in case you were wondering how you did!

Edit: People working in CS or a related field have a 9.59 avg score while the people that aren’t have a 9.61 avg.

People that have used AI image generators before got a 9.70 avg, while people that haven’t have a 9.39 avg score.

top 9 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old

[-] Eggyhead@artemis.camp 12 points 11 months ago

My wife, a graphic designer, just showed me a new feature added to Photoshop that basically allows AI to take a close up portrait and turn it into a full sized photo by generating ideal content around the subject using a few simple prompts. It’s really impressive. All she has to do is touch it up to make sure it’s believable and appealing. I don’t really care, since most advertisement photography is fake anyway, but I worry how propagandists are going to exploit the hell out of AI.

[-] M500@lemmy.ml 7 points 11 months ago

I’m happy to see these results. Although I think the results for the image with the avacado is skewed as I saw that image before in an article and it may have even been the thumbnail image.

[-] scottmeme@sh.itjust.works 5 points 11 months ago

Just got a 12.

A few of them actually surprised me even after running a bunch of AI models myself

[-] TheSlad@sh.itjust.works 4 points 11 months ago

Excluding the two spoilered images, i got 13/18. A coulple I felt kinda stupid about getting them wrong after the reveal. For the two spoilered images i think i would've gotten the avocado one from the nonsensical highlights and shape of the speechbubble tails, but the pen drawing definitely would've fooled me.

[-] BrianTheeBiscuiteer@lemmy.world 4 points 11 months ago

I tried to be honest about the sample images and got 50% right. I think the "drawings" are the hardest because some imperfections are intentional.

[-] SquirrelX@lemmy.world 2 points 11 months ago

I got a 9, while even knowing the two examples in this post, marking way too many as AI generated. But it got me thinking, seeing the deviantart links for the non-AI images: though maybe those are not generated by single prompts, there is a chance of heavy AI involvement in the process, one way or another. So I would actually be curious what the practical/applicable purpose of the survey was.

[-] SquirrelX@lemmy.world 2 points 11 months ago

Maybe to add, after having read some of the linked comments, that the survey is cool and all but that's it. It triggers people to explain their process of how they tried to spot things (as good experiment participants should), but I have only seen one comment on the purpose and methodology (as a researcher would). For whatever interesting research question, the data selection doesn't allow for insightful answers. We can interpret these results as we want, and as we can see, people are already taking what they want from it. Sincerely, Reviewer 2

this post was submitted on 08 Oct 2023

101 points (95.5% liked)

AI Generated Images

7067 readers

403 users here now

Community for AI image generation. Any models are allowed. Creativity is valuable! It is recommended to post the model used for reference, but not a rule.

No explicit violence, gore, or nudity.

This is not a NSFW community although exceptions are sometimes made. Any NSFW posts must be marked as NSFW and may be removed at any moderator's discretion. Any suggestive imagery may be removed at any time.

Refer to https://lemmynsfw.com/ for any NSFW imagery.

No misconduct: Harassment, Abuse or assault, Bullying, Illegal activity, Discrimination, Racism, Trolling, Bigotry.

AI Generated Videos are allowed under the same rules. Photosensitivity warning required for any flashing videos.

To embed images type:

“![](put image url in here)”

Follow all sh.itjust.works rules.

Community Challenge Past Entries

Related communities: