this post was submitted on 29 Jun 2026
-2 points (33.3% liked)

documentaryfilms

293 readers
4 users here now

A community to discuss,share and review documentary films.

founded 6 years ago
MODERATORS
 

Why is the carnivore diet a thing? Why do Jordan Peterson, Gwyneth Paltrow, Joe Rogan, and Tucker Carlson care what you eat? What exactly is 'slonking?' And behind all the sillyness, why does this all actually really really matter?

To help fund future work: Patreon: www.patreon.com/TheLeftistCooks Librapay: en.liberapay.com/theLeftistCooks/ Ko-fi: ko-fi.com/theleftistcooks

Join our community: discord.gg/XZmx8ZrgnJ

Citations: docs.google.com/document/d/1qnp_9bHGqBArSFDvoOr33l…

Featuring Interviews with: Olivia Wee: www.instagram.com/dietitian_oliviawee/ www.tiktok.com/@dietitian_oliviawee?is_from_webapp… Lily Hi'ilani www.tiktok.com/@hiililylani?_r=1&_t=ZN-97aecOaPpcU Rohan Davis ‪@rohanxdavis‬ Zoe Bee ‪@zoe_bee‬ ChrisWaves ‪@chriswaves‬

Thank you to 7thGenRising for sensitivity reading. Find their work here: www.instagram.com/7thgenrising

Our quote readers are all extremely talented creators. Please check out their work: ‪@rohanxdavis‬ ‪@QuestingRefuge‬ ‪@caelanconrad‬ ‪@squarecymbals‬ ‪@talistheintrovert‬ ‪@WillieMuse2‬ ‪@LolaSebastian‬ ‪@PillarofGarbage‬ ‪@hootshootman‬ ‪@chriswaves‬ ‪@Ember_Green‬ ‪@Leadhead‬ ‪@LegalKimchi‬ ‪@MainelyMandy‬ ‪@FDSignifire‬ ‪@JoseMariaLuna‬ ‪@ForeignManinaForeignLand‬ ‪@zoe_bee‬ ‪@JohntheDuncan‬ ‪@HogandDice‬ ‪@COLORMIND.mp4‬ ‪@bootstrap_paradox‬ ‪@elliotsangestevez‬ ‪@themorbidzoo‬ ‪@Rosencreutzzz‬ ‪@marsintheory‬ ‪@Aranock‬ ‪@Afterthoughts‬ ‪@SquidTips‬ ‪@alexander_avila‬ ‪@lily_lxndr‬ ‪@renegadecut‬ ‪@JoshWithParentheses‬

Chapters 00:00 Intro 00:19:41 Is It Good For You? 00:41:38 Meat and Masculinity 01:44:57 The Grift 02:26:30 The Pipeline 03:35:39 The Stakes 03:51:38 Absent Referents 04:06:36 Problems with Veganism 05:04:48 Ecofeminism 05:34:26 Final Thoughts

top 7 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] jet@hackertalks.com 2 points 10 hours ago (2 children)

a 6 hour video is alot to take in, here is a automated summary of the transcript

summerizerMain thesis

  • The meat-to-fascist pipeline is a symbolic link among meat, milk, eggs, rawness, supplements, masculinity, hierarchy, and authoritarian politics.
  • Food is culture, and reactionaries use food to code modern life as decadent, feminized, impure, weak, Jewish, foreign, or controlled by elites.
  • Anti-vegetable performance can sell authoritarian identity, climate denial, and distrust of public health without making every meat eater fascist.

Jordan Peterson and carnivore grift

  • Jordan Peterson begins as a psychology professor and becomes a right-wing celebrity whose all-beef performance keeps him politically useful and culturally visible.
  • Michaela Peterson turns severe health problems into a wellness-influencer career built on increasingly restrictive elimination diets ending in beef, salt, and water.
  • The Peterson story rejects ordinary nutrition and medicine, turns tiny personal datasets into certainty, and sells miracle-diet logic around autoimmune, digestive, mood, and dental problems.
  • Liver King shows the cruder version of the same machine: raw organs, testicles, steroids, hard-man insecurity, supplement money, and a young audience taught that weakness is personal failure.
  • Carnivore influencers make protein obsession, anti-plant disgust, masculinity panic, and right-wing politics feel like one coherent lifestyle.

Nutrition and restrictive diets

  • The carnivore diet removes legumes, seeds, nuts, fruits, vegetables, and fiber while concentrating meat, dairy, organs, marrow, eggs, and raw animal flesh.
  • Dietitian Olivia says the diet has no evidence base as a health intervention and creates foreseeable risks by removing essential nutrients and food groups.
  • Developed-world diets already contain enough protein; U.S. intake is about 20% above optimal, and excess protein can displace carbohydrates and fats.
  • Erectile-dysfunction literature is used against carnivore virility marketing: low intakes of vegetables, fruits, and nuts correlate with ED, while plant-based patterns correlate with lower ED risk.
  • Fiber is useful for gut function, metabolic health, microbiome activity, satiety, and disease prevention, while Fiber Menace and carnivore constipation rhetoric are dangerous misinformation.
  • Restrictive diets also feed orthorexia: clean-eating rules, gluten fear, self-diagnosis, and moralized avoidance can turn food into purity discipline.

Food signs, meat, and masculinity

  • Meat is not naturally masculine; cultures make it masculine through religion, advertising, gender hierarchy, militarism, and class power.
  • Fast-food and meat advertising sells burgers and barbecue as male freedom, while vegetables, plant-based meat, and environmental concern are feminized or mocked.
  • Studies and articles in the transcript link vegetarianism in men with social penalties, suspected queerness, and reduced masculine status.
  • Historically, meat marks class and empire: landlords and soldiers get meat, colonized and poor people get grain, potatoes, dairy labor, hunger, and extraction.
  • Ireland becomes an example of food colonialism: beef and dairy move outward while the people producing them are underfed or starved.
  • Carol Adams ties meat eating to objectification: animals and women are turned into consumable objects while the slaughtered subject disappears as an absent referent.

Race, empire, and the primitive fantasy

  • Gail Bederman's civilized-versus-primitive masculinity explains why insecure men reach for a staged primal identity when modern work and status feel unstable.
  • Liver King, Raw Egg Nationalist, and Bronze Age Pervert sell a fantasy of ancient male vitality by flattening Indigenous peoples, hunter-gatherers, and nonwhite cultures into props.
  • Paleo fantasies overstate raw meat, mammoth hunting, and universal male hunters while ignoring human dietary adaptability and evidence for women hunters.
  • The noble-savage move praises Indigenous foodways only when useful to white anti-vegan stories and discards actual Indigenous sovereignty, culture, and political needs.
  • The soy and Cracker Barrel panics show how plant-based food becomes an identity threat even though meat eaters consume massive soy indirectly through livestock.

Wellness, conspirituality, and diagonal politics

  • Wellness grift works by validating ordinary suffering, inventing toxins or hidden causes, and selling oils, supplements, detoxes, or restrictive diets as liberation.
  • Placebo benefits can be real, but they can also bind people to false healers, false mechanisms, and products that harm bodies or delay medical care.
  • Supplements are drugs without the cultural stigma of drugs: liver injury, emergency visits, contaminated sexual-performance pills, and L-tryptophan EMS show the danger.
  • Conspirituality joins left-coded wellness, libertarian consumer freedom, anti-vaccine politics, and right-wing distrust of institutions.
  • Joe Rogan, RFK, and diagonal influencers turn anti-establishment performance into a bridge from health anxiety to reactionary politics.

Milk, industry money, and epistemic vandalism

  • Milk becomes a racial and national symbol: government milk advertising, dairy subsidies, lactase-persistence theories, and white-pride milk stunts all attach purity to dairy.
  • The transcript attacks ideas that milk explains development, democracy, or Western success as genetics dressed up as history.
  • Meat companies and allied institutes use epistemic vandalism to break public understanding of food, climate, and health.
  • The EAT-Lancet Commission becomes a central target for meat-industry backlash because it links healthy diets with environmental limits.
  • Frank Mitloehner, CLEAR, the Dublin Declaration, the Denver Call, Rick Berman groups, and meat-funded messaging form a lobbying ecosystem against reduced meat consumption.
  • Peterson's broader network links meat culture to climate denial, Daily Wire oil money, ARC, Policy Exchange, and oligarch-backed conservative coordination.

Eco-fascism, animals, and diet purity

  • Raw Egg Nationalist and Bronze Age Pervert turn eggs, raw milk, meat, bodies, and climate fear into white-masculine survival politics.
  • Eco-fascists can accept climate danger while using it to demand closed borders, racial hierarchy, and violence against migrants.
  • Animals are not symbols only: cows, calves, chickens, fish, and slaughtered bodies are feeling beings inside systems of separation, killing, leather waste, pollution, and ecological collapse.
  • Hitler's likely vegetarianism and Modi's vegetarian Hindutva show that meat refusal alone does not defeat fascism when purity, caste, nationalism, antisemitism, or Islamophobia remain intact.
  • Vegetarianism and veganism are not moral magic; they must be joined to anti-fascist, anti-caste, anti-racist, labor-aware, and animal-liberation politics.

Veganism, ecofeminism, and practice

  • The transcript defends veganism while rejecting white vegan innocence, fake-meat consumerism, racialized farm-labor exploitation, and simplistic attacks on Indigenous subsistence.
  • Plant-based eating is cast as harm reduction inside a broader fight for food sovereignty, public health, labor justice, and climate survival.
  • Ecofeminism connects domination over animals, women, nature, colonized peoples, and the body as one hierarchy of control.
  • Naturalness is a bad guide: humans are interdependent, microbial, ecological, technological, and culturally made rather than pure, separate, or stable.
  • The practical answer is mutual aid, public health, dietitian expertise, community food production, reduced meat and dairy consumption, and refusal to carry meat-industry propaganda.
[–] jet@hackertalks.com 2 points 10 hours ago* (last edited 9 hours ago)

So far my biggest gripes are they ASSUME their medical position is true and that meat is bullshit.

I would hope they have looked at MD Georiga Ede's book - Change your diet change your mind, Noake's Ketogenic - the science of therapeutic carbohydrate restriction in human health, and Baszucki's Metabolic Mind foundation which is speed running the paper mill on diet and metabolic health.

Even if you dislike people who eat meat, you should take their position seriously if your going to credibly destroy them, that means you need to steel man their ideas, and find the best research and authorities to speak to current knowledge and efficaciousness.

Right now it's credible to say nutrition impacts mental health, and many people have a adverse reaction to carbohydrates. Autoimmune issues can also be rooted in nutrition, i.e. the discovery of gluten sensitivity was discovered by a autoimmune clinic in wwii when they had grain shortages.

Carnivore is a tool of extreme elimination, get to the base nutrition necessary for human life, and see how you do - if you improve then whatever your problem was had a nutrition component. By it's very nature the people who try carnivore are the sickest and least helped by current medicine, because why would a healthy person try a elimination diet if they don't have to? It's a giant pain in the ass.

anyway, y'all are welcome to come over to !carnivore@discuss.online if you have any questions.


Their source for keto being absolutely unhealthy and dangerous is a dietician... of course. Dietician's study a procedure, and apply the procedure, they do not do interventional science themselves, so this "expert" opinion is just against their training, not the manifest literature. She even says the main macronutrient is carbohydrates... I guess all those epileptic people not eating carbs are just a group hallucination? She says you can't survive without carbohydrates, so those epileptics must all be dead..... it's not consistent thinking - because a RD is 100% trained in the use of a ketogenic diet for epilepsy, so she could have added some nuance there... but no, guess they are all dead.

Nutrition is Nutrition, Medical is Medical.

That was important, they made a slide and bolded it! Guess that means your diet and food have no impact on medical conditions? Right? This is a professional dietician after all. All those drinkers with fatty liver disease can drink up without worrying about their medical condition. It's a great sound bite but its very narrow thinking. Obviously human health is impacted by the food people eat.

There is not shortage of actual medical doctors in the nutrition space, they really should have asked for a steel man position to tear down... keto is literally the most studied dietary pattern in the interventional literature. This RD could talk to any of the hundreds of practicing doctors on this list https://www.dietdoctor.com/low-carb/doctors/all or reach out to any of the paper authors.... but no

[–] jet@hackertalks.com 2 points 10 hours ago

and the references (too big to fit into the original message above)

auto-discovered referencesReferences

[–] Treczoks@lemmy.world 3 points 1 day ago (1 children)
[–] jet@hackertalks.com 3 points 8 hours ago

and

That is alot of fascists who love vegetables...

I suspect the people who made this video don't care about facts and counter examples so much

[–] davel@lemmy.ml 3 points 1 day ago (1 children)

I’ve watched several of their video essays, including one that’s almost two hours long. This one’s three times longer. Bonkers

[–] TropicalDingdong@lemmy.world 2 points 1 day ago

Same, 6 hours is pushing it and I go for longer format all the time. Like what is this a season of game of thrones?