458
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] Fedizen@lemmy.world 77 points 6 months ago

Again like the tiktok ban: Rather than passing real privacy laws we're passing racism laws and pretending this helps privacy and security.

[-] FiniteBanjo@lemmy.today 39 points 6 months ago

The CCP might be all Chinese and the Chinese Populace might be +91% Han Chinese but that in no way makes laws which target a hostile foreign dictatorship equate to "racism".

[-] UnderpantsWeevil@lemmy.world 19 points 6 months ago

the Chinese Populace might be +91% Han Chinese

I'll never understand how a country with 1.4B people gets labeled "homogenous" by race counters, but a continent with with 800M, like Europe, is able to recognize dozens of cultures and subcultures.

Would you even guess that China has over 300 living languages inside its borders?

[-] NIB@lemmy.world 10 points 6 months ago* (last edited 6 months ago)

Because not many europeans primarily identify as "european first". This is slowly changing but for the most part, people identify by whatever european nation they inhabit. But i bet most chinese identify as "chinese first" instead of whatever region/city they are from.

In fact, China likes to brag about how "advanced" they are, that they solved this "issue" centuries ago, while the EU is currently trying to "copy them".

TLDR : If you ask a chinese tourist "where are you from?", they will answer "China". If you ask a european the same, noone will say "Europe/EU".

[-] vaultdweller013@sh.itjust.works 6 points 6 months ago

You are looking at it from the perspective of a westerner post springtime of nations. As I understand it a lot of Chinese people see it more like the Romans, wherein they may be different but they are all Chinese. Also China has been committing cultural genocide and assimilation against groups within their borders for millenia, this has resulted in what can best be described as a very broad cultural and ethnic identity.

[-] UnderpantsWeevil@lemmy.world -4 points 6 months ago* (last edited 6 months ago)

So you think the Chinese are just naturally genocidal? And that's why the Yao and Zhuang and Bai and Mongolian people don't count as distinct ethnic groups?

Meanwhile, the Welsh, the English, the Irish, and the Scottish do count because... the English have been historically so peaceful and egalitarian?

[-] vaultdweller013@sh.itjust.works 5 points 6 months ago

When the fuck did I say that their naturally that way? Its a control tool, the Romans also used it to a degree. Its pretty hard to keep an empire as big as China going for severap Millenia without doing that type of shit.

Also did I say that I didnt recognize the Yao, Zhuang, Bai, and Mongols as distinct ethno cultural groups? I was talking on my understanding of how quite a lot of Chinese folks see themselves, if you want my opinion on it then Id say the Han identity is probably split them into at least a dozen groups and its just cultural genocide and colonialism all the way down. But I refuse to recognize the concept of an American culture so im a bit biased on that front.

And then finally I didnt know Irish, Scots, and Welsh thoughly identify with the English silly me. Seriously I will repeat myself, I was referring to the dominant groupsing in China not minority groups. But you do allow to make a solid point, who embrases and attemps to enforce the "British" identity the most is it the Scots, Irish, and Welsh or is it the colonialist bastards in the south of England? I am very aware of Englands tendency towards cultural genocide within Great Britain and Ireland, afterall half my ancestors fled to North America to escape the fucking Saxons.

[-] yogurt@lemm.ee 1 points 6 months ago

If you don't get the historical or political reason why something is the way it is then it seems "natural" by default. China never had a several millennia empire unless you think Europe is also a several millennia empire. The modern concept of Han is the same thing you're doing when you say "fucking Saxons". The Saxons didn't do anything, the imperial system and opposition to it is racialized. From the 1600s-1900s Han wasn't the dominant group in China, the Qing dynasty had a Manchu identity, and they executed people for expressing Han culture. Opposition to oppression and corruption and European imperial influence was racialized as Han nationalism.

CCP politics straddles an anti-colonial idea of Chinese identity where the diaspora of people shipped around European empires to build railroads or farm plantations are still Chinese, and then also a geographic identity that all those millennia of different systems whether Mongol or Manchu or Han or split up into 100 different states are all equally Chinese.

[-] vaultdweller013@sh.itjust.works 1 points 6 months ago

Given the fact that China keeps reuniting into a variably centralized series of states that claim continuity from eachother id say that is a several millenia old empire, warlord eras not withstanding. All im doing is applying the same rules a lot of folks including myself use for Rome, pre Roman Egypt, France, or most other empires.

As for ruling cultures, well whoopedy doo the Manchus had problem with the biggest culture that they ruled over, thats so fucking common for ruling cultures that it barely even registers in my mind as notable. Sure it went on for about 300 years but thats still a drop in the rather large bucket that is Chinese hostory. Hell id say its more notable when a ruling culture starts out trying to assimilate and hybridize with those they rule, the Normans come to mind on that one.

Frankly I dont care what the fucken CCP claims, empires and states spew a lot of shit from their mouths when the only thing that should be coming out is their own blood. I only care what the common people have to say not some weakling politicians or overworked bureaucrat have to say.

And then finally the problems my ancestors had was with the southern English aka the Saxons, I know who fucked over my ancestors and I will carry on this grudge from them until every Saxon aristocrat and oligarch are lashed to crosses.

[-] retrospectology@lemmy.world 5 points 6 months ago* (last edited 6 months ago)

European countries aren't totalitarian states. This isn't a question of culture, it's an issue regarding the one and only state power that's making decisions.

This is the danger of being lulled into thinking China is a normal country. Yes, there are long histories in China and are (vanishing) diverse cultures in China but that's irrelevant when talking about the actions of the state, which is all encompassing and overrules culture and diversity every time.

It's the state that owns and controls these companies, it's the state that dictates their policy and usage, and since the state is fascist and actively seeking to undermine democracy across the global, it is wise to treat the products of that state as a threat.

[-] UnderpantsWeevil@lemmy.world 0 points 6 months ago

European countries aren’t totalitarian states.

I know some Irish Republicans, Spanish Catalonians, German anti-Zionist political prisoners, and ... waves hand at Poland, Hungary, and Russia

Quite a few native Europeans who would tell you differently.

This is the danger of being lulled into thinking China is a normal country

I don't think the folks on Lemmy are at any risk of that.

It’s the state that owns and controls these companies

Imagine thinking government should dictate the terms of business and not the other way around.

[-] retrospectology@lemmy.world 1 points 6 months ago

I know some Irish Republicans, Spanish Catalonians, German anti-Zionist political prisoners, and … waves hand at Poland, Hungary, and Russia

Quite a few native Europeans who would tell you differently.

Europe has some authoritarian governments, not totalitarian dictatorships that approach anywhere near the all-encompassing control of the CCP. Hungary maybe I guess, which isn't a country I'd recommend taking tech from either.

Ireland is not comparable to China though, that's an extreme reach. We're not talking about right-wing groups seeking power within democracies, we're talking about uni-party state control.

I don’t think the folks on Lemmy are at any risk of that.

Lemmy definitely has a tankie infestation already. I got banned from lemmy.ml for discussing Tiananmen and Hong Kong. Pointing out that the Great Leap Forward resulted in millions of deaths was labeled "cia misinformation" by the mods. It's a throughly compromised instance.

Lemmy users are not immune to tankie and Rusdian trolls, and thinking that they are is actually a weakness that gets exploited by those bad actors.

Imagine thinking government should dictate the terms of business and not the other way around.

Normal regulatory duties of a government are a far cry from the state having total ownership and control of business and using that control as part of a coercive campaign to suppress human rights, dissent and individual freedoms.

Whatever authoritarianism is festering in other countries, China is still on an entirely different level, it's not really a question.

[-] UnderpantsWeevil@lemmy.world 0 points 6 months ago

Europe has some authoritarian governments, not totalitarian dictatorships

Totalitarianism is always when the other guy does it. Never question the modem day police/surveillance state at home. Certainly don't ask about our colonies abroad, or their paramilitary death squads and torture prisons financed with domestic capital.

Lemmy definitely has a tankie infestation

It's got an anti-war infestation that's regularly accused of being tankies for failing to clap for the correct set of tanks.

Normal regulatory duties of a government are a far cry from the state having total ownership and control of business

Calmly explaining this to my US Postal Service and my Tennessee Valley Authority

[-] retrospectology@lemmy.world 1 points 6 months ago

Totalitarianism is always when the other guy does it

No...totalitarianism is an actual distinct system of governance when the state controls every aspect of daily life, communication and economic activity. It's an actual word with meaning.

It’s got an anti-war infestation that’s regularly accused of being tankies for failing to clap for the correct set of tanks.

Ok, I'm not sure if we're talking through a translator app or something, but I didn't get banned from lemmy.ml for being "pro-war" I got banned for mentioning a historical fact about the Great Leap Forward and acknowledging other atrocities like the genocide occurring in Xinjiang.

If someone is anti-war they would be against those types of things as well. Tankies instead deny that those events occurred/are occurring, that's why they're so easy to spot and how people know they're on Lemmy -- they literally can't condemn the CCP for any of the things they purport to be against when it comes to other countries, since it's counter-productive to their true goals to criticize the CCP.

By contrast an honestly anti-war progressive type of person would be just as clear-eyed about their own government as they are the CCP. That's being anti-war, you can't be selective or try to ignore degrees of difference just because it's politically uncomfortable, that's just being a mouth-piece for a specific flavor of authoritarianism.

Calmly explaining this to my US Postal Service and my Tennessee Valley Authority

Again, running public services is not the same as the state owning and controlling all businness and industry. If the Post Office was used to control speech, that would be totalitarian use of a public service.

I think you're just being obtuse at this point. You might be down for totalitarianism and the abolishment of individual freedoms, most people are not. Since, you know, having no rights kind of suck ass.

[-] UnderpantsWeevil@lemmy.world 0 points 6 months ago

totalitarianism is an actual distinct system of governance when the state controls every aspect of daily life

Imagine saying that in a country with the highest prison population in the world

[-] noisefree@lemmy.world 1 points 6 months ago

banned

Believe it or not, also Rule 1. Wait, wrong instance.

[-] FiniteBanjo@lemmy.today 3 points 6 months ago

I can see how this might seem like a hexbear or ml thread from the pro-ccp comments on this post, lol.

this post was submitted on 16 Jun 2024
458 points (98.9% liked)

Technology

60053 readers
2853 users here now

This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.


Our Rules


  1. Follow the lemmy.world rules.
  2. Only tech related content.
  3. Be excellent to each another!
  4. Mod approved content bots can post up to 10 articles per day.
  5. Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted.
  6. Politics threads may be removed.
  7. No memes allowed as posts, OK to post as comments.
  8. Only approved bots from the list below, to ask if your bot can be added please contact us.
  9. Check for duplicates before posting, duplicates may be removed

Approved Bots


founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS