Makeplayingcards (makeplayingcards.com) is one of the better proxying sites, they're very consistent and not very expensive. you can use a website like MPC Autofill (mpcfill.com) to create an xml file of the cards you want printed, then take that to MPC for the printing. Mpcfill also lets you pick individual card arts for every card, or upload your own if you want, it's very convenient. I also recently started playing again, and proxying everything with cards that actually feel like magic cards has been a game changer. if I had to print everything out on printer paper and use those I imagine it would be much less fun.
e: for some reason the direct links weren't working so I just added them on their own


my political party based on intellectual dishonesty is being intellectually dishonest!

I'm a Maoist now, Jack!
crush Zionism into dust
for sure! here's two rows of cards; the ones on the top are proxies, and the ones on the bottom are legit cards
the proxies have a very slight blur on the text if you look very closely, but sleeved up in a deck they're indistinguishable.
here's a bit of a closer look at the pridemate:
I also like to change the backs of the cards to ensure everyone (including myself) knows they're fake, so that I don't accidentally trade them and scam someone