One of my first memories of being disillusioned with media, having my hopes up and being let down was TPM. I went and saw it, kinda convinced myself it was cool...
Then a couple days later, someone was asking me about, and they asked what happened. I took a moment to think and finally had to come back and say 'idk, I guess nothing really'.
Shining Force
It started out really slow, but now I'm mid-late game. I've got a band of characters I like and I'm on the cusp of promoting most of them.
It's older and less refined than other games I've played in the genre (ie, Fire Emblems), but it's been a good time.