Both approaches can make for great games. In my book, a bigger issue in the base version of Cyberpunk arguably suffers due to is Johnny Silverhand's regular presence and commentary sometimes feeling like it can undercut that game's ability not to fill moments of silence that'd be perfect for Bladerunner-style broody contemplation with chatter that may not add much to proceedings.
Does this site not employ editors? That is some of the worst writing I’ve seen online. I would accuse it of being slop but I don’t even think slop can write a sentence that poorly.