Why are you rating the game on how conventionally attractive the characters are anyway? It's a game, not a horny boomer ad for beer.
Actually, only slightly related, but one thing annoying about US movies and TV compared to say, British stuff is that every actor looks too much like a fucking actor. What I mean is, they all look generically handsome/beautiful and it makes no sense because in real life not everyone looks like that. In fact most people don't. I'm not saying don't cast conventionally attractive people, but maybe don't have your entire cast look like they came from a runway? It makes your movie look too fake.