1089
submitted 9 months ago by bobby_hill@lemmy.world to c/atheism@lemmy.world
top 50 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[-] De_Narm@lemmy.world 95 points 9 months ago

I never got this. They say he is omnipotent, therefore he does not perceive time in a linear way like we do. He knows everything that ever was, is and will be all at once. So there is not much to test here. Either he does the things needed to make me a believer or he doesn't. It's his choice and not mine. Free will is meaningless here, even if it does exist, he does already knows my choice before I make it or he is not omnipotent.

[-] joseangel@lemmy.world 75 points 9 months ago

"Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able? Then he is not omnipotent. Is he able, but not willing? Then he is malevolent. Is he both able and willing? Then whence cometh evil? Is he neither able nor willing? Then why call him God?" - Epicurus

[-] Syrc@lemmy.world 6 points 9 months ago

~~Ackshually~~ it was probably not Epicurus, but Sextus Empiricus. From the surviving writings it seems Epicurus was really not fond of Atheists.

(Doesn’t change that it’s a great argument, I just hate that we don’t have a definite source for it)

load more comments (6 replies)
[-] 0x0@lemmy.dbzer0.com 37 points 9 months ago

Sure, but "God works in mysterious ways," so it's not my responsibility to clear up any paradoxes that arise from my religious axioms. Get with the program.

[-] De_Narm@lemmy.world 36 points 9 months ago

"God works in mysterious ways" is a nice way of describing him as a Lovecraftian horror we cannot possibly understand.

[-] ubermeisters@lemmy.world 12 points 9 months ago

Well have you ever read the depictions of angels in the Bible? Very lovecraftian. You may even say it's a precisely what inspired Lovecraft.

load more comments (3 replies)
[-] uriel238@lemmy.blahaj.zone 9 points 9 months ago

Playing The Sims 2 helped make His mysterious ways less mysterious but the same amount of cosmic horror.

load more comments (1 replies)
load more comments (1 replies)
[-] ubermeisters@lemmy.world 18 points 9 months ago* (last edited 9 months ago)

It's pretty clear in the Bible that you were created to worship God so your fate has been sealed since day one as far as that book is concerned. Christians get real sensitive when you start asking about the specifics of all the omnis (omniscient, omnipotent, omnipresent) because they necessitate some unfriendly truths like "God created original sin intentionally" and "how the fuck do you die and go to hell as gods equally omni son?" "CAN God create a fart so big that even HIS butthole can't fart it??"

[-] Chunk@lemmy.world 10 points 9 months ago* (last edited 9 months ago)

For those unaware, the original theological question is

Can God create a rock so large he cannot lift it?

The answer, and I'm not shitting you, is

Yes. God can make a boulder so large he cannot lift it. And then he can lift it anyway.

load more comments (2 replies)
[-] bobby_hill@lemmy.world 10 points 9 months ago

"CAN God create a fart so big that even HIS butthole can't fart it??"

Asking the real questions

load more comments (1 replies)
[-] CarbonIceDragon@pawb.social 15 points 9 months ago* (last edited 9 months ago)

Hypothetically, if such an entity did exist, shouldn't that same logic also extend to knowing his own future choices? Since they already know everything that will happen, they also know everything that they themselves are going to do, and therefore, have essentially no agency themselves, because even if their power is infinite, it is already set beforehand what they are going to use that power for and they are essentially just along for the ride?

For that matter, if they know everything, and therefore know everything at all points in time all at once and so shouldn't perceive time linearly, then there is no room for such a being to really engage in information processing, since that requires taking in information, and doing something with it to produce new information, and this kind of being has already taken in all the information possible from the very beginning, does not experience a meaningful flow of time (and so cannot experience change with which to apply to that input), and already has all the outputs from the very beginning too. Since thinking is a form of information processing, it occurs to me a truly omniscient being like this should basically be a philosophical zombie; basically an unconscious object of incredible scope that merely appears to be a conscious thinking entity to humans due to our limited perception of time.

[-] Sterile_Technique@lemmy.world 9 points 9 months ago

As a thought experiment, if we think of a god as a being that exists in the 5th dimension, it could be omnipotent/omniscient to the lower 4 (3 spacial + time) but only have a limited presence/influence regarding things like probability, and no influence whatsoever on things like other realities.

Similar to how we exist in the 4th dimension and can fully manipulate the lower three; but while we exist and are aware of time, we can't manipulate it outside of trying to nudge it with extreme speed or gravity.

A god in 5th dimension then would kinda look like someone playing the Sims and making use of save states to try to optimize every decision in the game; and while you might be aware that other games exist, -this- one can only ever be Sims.

This would make omnipotence a question of scope - to the individual sim, the player is all powerful in the ways that an individual sim can experience, so, omnipotent; but that player can't do shit to Minecraft, or instances of Sims running on other computers, so, simultaneously not omnipotent.

Basically the Many Worlds theory, but each reality would have its own god.

...which still doesn't really pass the all-knowing, all-powerful, all-good test, but it does at least frame the concept of god in a more interesting way from a mythology perspective.

No religion that I'm aware of acknowledges things like dimensions, but then they present their god as existing in a way that's clearly outside the scope of the 4 we experience... So, there's wiggle room even in actual religious lore in how we package things like "omnipotence".

[-] phx@lemmy.world 7 points 9 months ago

I love movies and books that touch on topics like this, like situations where you've got a super-being but they build in limitations.

  • one who can "see" into the future for hundreds of years but can only actually view one timeline simultaneously and in real-time (meaning they could see any event in the future but would need to burn time in "the now" like watching a recorded video)

  • beings that constantly lose track of what the "current" reality/timeline is in a seas of possibilities (MIB3's "Griffin" is a fun example of this)

  • being able to know what significant future events will occur but unable to influence whether they do or not. Unavoidable destiny (e.g. Emma's Death in "the Time Machine" is unavoidable, though the exact many it occurs changes)

  • Knowing what "bad things" will happen but still being on the "best track" timeline as deviations make things worse (Loki, Butterfly Effect)

  • Macro level knowledge overcrowding micro level suffering in the backdrop of inter-galactic scales and infinite time

  • semi-autonomous superpowers commanded by unfathomable beings without fine control and a limited self-awareness

None of this of course is an argument for the existence of an actual deity that loves us but ignores us, however they are fun ways to think of how one might know the future yet not want or be able to change it.

[-] Slowy@lemmy.world 5 points 9 months ago

This only exists if there is one possible outcome, it’s possible for the future to be undetermined, and still have an omniscient being know all future possibilities. They would know the infinite possible outcomes of their choices, all the iterations, but would still have free will to decide which path is followed. In this scenario people still don’t have free will because of the omniscience problem.

[-] CarbonIceDragon@pawb.social 8 points 9 months ago

Shouldn't they still know which path they will end up choosing to take?

load more comments (1 replies)
load more comments (1 replies)
[-] jaybone@lemmy.world 10 points 9 months ago

I think there was this guy Calvin who already pointed that out.

[-] SpaceNoodle@lemmy.world 7 points 9 months ago

Omnipotent means "all-powerful." Omniscient means "all-knowing."

[-] thatsTheCatch@lemmy.nz 9 points 9 months ago

Correct. But the Christian belief is that God is also omniscient. He is the three omnis: omnipotent, omniscient, and omnipresent

[-] ubermeisters@lemmy.world 6 points 9 months ago

Ahh yes more trinities. My favorite is the Father (gets all 3 onnis), Son(oops you can be killed apparently, so only 2 omnis then?) and the holy spirit (3 omnis).

load more comments (7 replies)
load more comments (6 replies)
load more comments (1 replies)
[-] WindowsEnjoyer@sh.itjust.works 80 points 9 months ago
[-] Syrc@lemmy.world 35 points 9 months ago

I remember this one with the caption “but if you stop it it’s going to be unfair for the people that already died”

load more comments (1 replies)
[-] bobby_hill@lemmy.world 8 points 9 months ago

This is literally ~~1984~~ COVID19

[-] xenoclast@lemmy.world 8 points 9 months ago

Literally all Capitalism

[-] RIP_Cheems@lemmy.world 6 points 9 months ago
load more comments (1 replies)
[-] Chunk@lemmy.world 50 points 9 months ago

You are an omniscient and all powerful God.

You create someone who is tortured and killed in a war at the age of 2.

You are a benevolent God because you helped that person experience the full spectrum of what life has to offer.

The 2 year old did not acknowledge your supreme authority because you did not give it a developed brain to grasp the concept and so they burn in hell for eternity, never able to fully comprehend what happened to them. Their entire existence is one of suffering and unexplainable agony.

You are a benevolent God.

[-] bobby_hill@lemmy.world 12 points 9 months ago
load more comments (1 replies)
[-] FlyingSquid@lemmy.world 48 points 9 months ago

If god is all-knowing, he knew I would grow up an atheist. If god is all-powerful, he hasn't done anything about it. So I guess he's okay with it.

[-] samus12345@lemmy.world 11 points 9 months ago

Oh, no, it would be wrong for him to do anything to interfere with your free will! But it's totally fine for his worshipers to do so.

load more comments (2 replies)
load more comments (5 replies)
[-] MajorHavoc@lemmy.world 45 points 9 months ago

I took a quick poll of people tied to the tracks, and a majority reported that:

  1. I'm good.
  2. Please get us off these tracks.
[-] Eheran@lemmy.world 5 points 9 months ago

Hahaha, thank you.

load more comments (2 replies)
[-] platypus_plumba@lemmy.world 39 points 9 months ago

Plus, he also knew you wouldn't accept him even before he created you.

[-] ILikeBoobies@lemmy.ca 34 points 9 months ago

God only kills people he knows will be evil

Just remember next time you see a make a wish kid that they are literally worse than Hitler

[-] Chunk@lemmy.world 12 points 9 months ago

Dude blood cancer kids are worse than Hitler. Do you know how many times I'm watching Rick and Morty and I get interrupted by the make a wish foundation? It's infuriating.

I mean, Hitler was a bad guy but he did kill Hitler!

/s

Holy fuck that post is dripping with sarcastic and it still hurt to write.

load more comments (1 replies)
[-] electrogamerman@lemmy.world 5 points 9 months ago

Didn't Hitler killed a lot of gay men? How many gay men has the make a wish kid killed? Check mate, Atheists.

[-] nucleative@lemmy.world 32 points 9 months ago

I brought a question like this up in a church. It was not well received.

[-] CrayonRosary@lemmy.world 17 points 9 months ago

No, because you define "evil" as "against your will", and "good" as "anything you do".

[-] ICastFist@programming.dev 17 points 9 months ago

Stop judging me by how I play Rollercoaster Tycoon >:(

[-] makyo@lemmy.world 15 points 9 months ago

Plus, as said omnipotent creator you leave only highly questionable 'evidence' of your existence

load more comments (3 replies)
[-] Spzi@lemm.ee 10 points 9 months ago

He'S nOt EvIl, He SaVeS yOu!

[-] gabrielhidasy@lemmy.world 9 points 9 months ago

You forgot the "they accept you as the creator, and you let the trolley hit anyway"

load more comments (3 replies)
[-] aquinteros@lemmy.world 7 points 9 months ago

if only it was just death by trolley... but no no.. ists actually burning for the eternity in a fiery pit of lava and ash, you know, love.

load more comments
view more: next ›
this post was submitted on 08 Oct 2023
1089 points (94.9% liked)

Atheism

3810 readers
181 users here now

Community Guide


Archive Today will help you look at paywalled content the way search engines see it.


Statement of Purpose

Acceptable

Unacceptable

Depending on severity, you might be warned before adverse action is taken.

Inadvisable


Application of warnings or bans will be subject to moderator discretion. Feel free to appeal. If changes to the guidelines are necessary, they will be adjusted.


If you vocally harass or discriminate against any individual member, you will be removed.

Likewise, if you are a member, sympathizer or a resemblant of a group that is known to largely hate, mock, discriminate against, and/or want to take lives of any other group of people, and you were provably vocal about your hate, then you you will be banned on sight.

Provable means able to provide proof to the moderation, and, if necessary, to the community.

 ~ /c/nostupidquestions

If you want your space listed in this sidebar and it is especially relevant to the atheist or skeptic communities, PM DancingPickle and we'll have a look!


Connect with Atheists

Help and Support Links

Streaming Media

This is mostly YouTube at the moment. Podcasts and similar media - especially on federated platforms - may also feature here.

Orgs, Blogs, Zines

Mainstream

Bibliography

Start here...

...proceed here.

Proselytize Religion

From Reddit

As a community with an interest in providing the best resources to its members, the following wiki links are provided as historical reference until we can establish our own.

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS