would be cool if inertia wasn't a thing
People have a terrible understanding of orbital mechanics and apparent weightlessness. It's not like gravity just stops affecting you after you get out of the atmosphere. Getting out of the atmosphere is the easy part of getting to orbit. Going sideways fast enough is the hard part.
I feel like everyone should play KSP, just to get a taste of it
I used to baby sit a friend's kid when he was a wee lad, frankly we spent most time playing KSP. Used to give him challenges like if he could build a ship using x amount of parts and make orbit would let him order out pizza instead of food his mom prepared for us. He rarely succeeded at first but apparently kept at it long after I stopped mentoring him and apparently is now going to school to be an aerospace engineer. And before all that his mom could never get him to do his math homework as a tyke.
Pizza has a strange powers over humans. Good job friend.
The real friends is the pizza we make along the way.
Definitely not all those kerbals stranded on Duna. He never did figure out how to properly make it there and back
What a great origin story
Nothing got me working on math quite like trying to figure out my ship's ∆v back in 2014 before I installed Kerbal Engineer
That's where I learned about it.
Watching the trajectory change as you accelerate is so satisfying...
what? are you telling me I couldn't reach the other side of the planet by jumping for 12h ?
Also, wind.
Anon's airship has inertial dampeners. Checkmate, atheists.
That's easy, instead of accelerating towards your destination you just have to brake and stop moving to let the earth move under you, checkmate physics
This is dumb as shit. Hot air balloons only go so high, less than 70k feet according to records. They only stay aloft if the heat is continually applied, if not, air cools and they sink. They move with the air, and the air moves with the planet.
This doesn’t work for the same reason jumping in an airplane doesn’t slam you into the back wall.
I don't think it was posted because it was brilliant…
Ok but they're going really really high up
If you go much higher the balloon will leak heat through black body radiation faster than you'll be able to heat it. And even if you insulated the balloon in a way that didn't add too much weight you'd eventually get to the top of the atmosphere and hot air balloons won't go into space because they don't have any propulsion systems.
If you fill it with helium, it will go into space, and then it will immediately explode.
Balloons using hydrogen can reach 33 miles. But even then the atmosphere still moves with the ground.
Yeah, but anon smart, u dumb. Checkmate.
This is just playing into the hands of big basket.
I hope troll logic makes a comeback
ikr they forgor to say "Problem?"
I hope so too, given how many people are taking this seriously.
Missed opportunity there: get more seats installed or attach the balloon to a bus or something, I don't know - and whenever the earth below rotates to where your destination is, just yeet yourself out Felix Baumgartner style.
More people means more profit and fewer busloon trips needed, meaning the eco footprint is smaller and you'll get a Christmas card off a random polar bear/penguin thanking you your service.
The only minor inconvenience I can think of is that your parachute effectively takes up your carry-on luggage allowance so you'll have to pay to check anything that doesn't fit in your pockets, but other than that I think you're good to go
Don't forget to thank the busdriver
I think in a balloon bus, it's a balldriver
attach the balloon to a bus
Yo boys we're going on the battle bus (sorry for my terrible joke, it just reminded me that I'm fucking old because this was popular like 6 years ago)
just yeet yourself out Felix Baumgartner style.
this would be so awesome. i'd spend the whole time trying to come up with something clever to say, right before the yeeting.
I’m not a rocket surgeon, but I think the amount of energy required to reach orbit is higher than what a jet would use.
Nah, weather balloons can get really really high. The problem here is, the atmosphere doesn’t “end” it just gets thinner and thinner. You would still spin with the earth, just a bit slower.
And winds aloft are often going much much faster than on the ground.
And temps, youd have to do a lot to keep warm.
And pressurization, at ~60k ft your blood boils.
That’s how you make your money! Sell them suits!
The suits don’t have to work. The customer won’t complain either way.
Not exactly brain science is it.
Your move, globe heads.
Randall Munroe answered that in detail - https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/
That does not answer the question. The balloon is not going to orbit, high atmospheric balloons exist and do not require propulsion.
The reason it won't work is because the atmosphere is coupled to the ground and rotates with the ground.
Conservation of momentum.
You don't suddenly stop moving with the Earth just because you're no longer standing on terra firma. Like, if you throw a ball it doesn't just suddenly fall straight to the ground once it leaves your hand.
Plus, in a hot air balloon you're still in the atmosphere... Which is also moving. But even if you were in the total vacuum of space, the above applies and you still wouldn't remain stationary without actively countering the momentum you already have. And then you'd just be pulled in by gravity, unless you actively counter that too. And all that countering of forces is way more costly with fuel than simply accounting for the fact you're already moving at super high speeds along with the rotation of the planet.
What if instead of doing this we built a really tall pole and shot people up it on a motorized basket and then clamped it at the top so we could save fuel?
Going from the US to Japan or China by hot air balloon would mean going the long way over Europe due to the jet stream, this would take more than 12h.
If they don't understand gravity, I suspect the jet stream will be harder to grasp
I think he'd run out of oxygen that high up wouldn't he? Or it would get too cold for the balloon to stay inflated if he didn't freeze to death first? Also, is a hot air balloon even capable of lifting a 500lb man-child that high? Would there even be room for his mobility scooter, his snacks and his high performance gaming PC?
The density of the air becomes so thin that I don't think you could have a container for enough hot air that wouldn't weigh more than the lift provided. Helium weather balloons end up getting so large because of the pressure difference that they end up bursting at those altitudes.
Greentext
This is a place to share greentexts and witness the confounding life of Anon. If you're new to the Greentext community, think of it as a sort of zoo with Anon as the main attraction.
Be warned:
- Anon is often crazy.
- Anon is often depressed.
- Anon frequently shares thoughts that are immature, offensive, or incomprehensible.
If you find yourself getting angry (or god forbid, agreeing) with something Anon has said, you might be doing it wrong.