this meme is wrong
what really happens is that this thiopropenal S-oxide attacks free thiol in one receptor that usually detects spicy smells, much like about any modern tear gas (CN, CS, CR. also allyl isothiocyanate from mustard and many, many, many other alkylating things). there's no acid involved
I don't know whether to believe the meme or the comment on the meme.
Onions spew enzymes and sulfenic acid when their skin is broken. These compounds combine to produce propanethial S-oxide, an irritating gas.
Propanethial S-oxide is a lachrymatory agent, meaning that it generates tears when it touches the eye. Propanethial S-oxide turns into sulfuric acid when it touches the water layer that covers and protects your eyeballs.
I'm not a chemistry guy though.
I am especially sensitive to this. I’ve found that using a very, very sharp knife can help, but some onions are especially strong. At that point I’m breaking out the swimming goggles.
I thought I was the only one who cuts onion with goggles. If I only need one onion I don't need them if I am quick enough, but if I need more than that, I always whip out swimming goggles.
Run your wrists, palm up, under cold water. It's black magic. It will stop it almost instantly.
I am going to try this, but I’d really like to know why it works. Someone else suggested cold water on the knife. Do the irritant molecules from the onion react with the water on your hands/wrists/knife before getting up in your eyes?
Onion make gas. Gas stick to tear on eyeball. Tears turn acidic, eyeball hurt.
Bring tears to onion, gas already react so no can hurt real eyeball. That why bring water (fake eyeball) to onion when cut.
Gud esplaind
Try slicing a lime or lemon before cutting onions.
Apparently doing this will literally help
I think that just generally helps with life
I don’t get it, bite into something, or eat something sweet?
Holding bread in your mouth.
At some point I started running cold water on the knife before cutting and onion, and it seems to help. Does anyone know if there’s science behind this, or am I making shit up?
Others in this thread have pointed out that running cold water over your arms helps. So maybe while you wet your blade, your arms get wet too...?
Maybe it lubricates the knife so that it crushes fewer onion cells. That is the reason a sharper knife also works. Or the water dissolves part of the escaping gas. I think it might be both.
my guess would be that it dilutes the stuff in onion cells that reacts and creates the irritating gas, and maybe even prevents the reaction from happening or just dissolves the gas into the water instead
It was fun to discover that contact lenses are like a superpower when it comes to cutting onions. Finally, a benefit to being utterly blind!
It's hard, but don't blink. If you blink it gets under your eyelids. If you don't, the tears just continuously wash it down.
I just got a knife sharpener and it actually helps.
After sharpening, my eyes couldn’t even tell that I was cutting an onion.
Instructions unclear, now I have pointy eyes
Instructions unclear, I can't see anymore
my eyes couldn’t even tell that I was cutting an onion.
Because you have sharpened and blinded yourself......
this works because the pain is caused by an irritating gas released when you crush the onion cells and some compounds mix together and react, with a sharp knife fewer cells are crushed so there's less gas
You can also heavily dehydrate yourself if you don't wanna cry, might work haven't tried it yet
Run cold water on your wrists. Problem solved.
Doesnt it literally make the gas used in ww1 in ur eyes.
no
Great. Another factoid I can throw at people
is that why wetting it reduces the pain?
No, it's about the shock of the cold on your nervous system.
A place for majestic STEMLORD peacocking, as well as memes about the realities of working in a lab.
Rules
This is a science community. We use the Dawkins definition of meme.
