1178
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 06 Oct 2023
1178 points (97.8% liked)
Uplifting News
10796 readers
1142 users here now
Welcome to /c/UpliftingNews, a dedicated space where optimism and positivity converge to bring you the most heartening and inspiring stories from around the world. We strive to curate and share content that lights up your day, invigorates your spirit, and inspires you to spread positivity in your own way. This is a sanctuary for those seeking a break from the incessant negativity often found in today's news cycle. From acts of everyday kindness to large-scale philanthropic efforts, from individual achievements to community triumphs, we bring you news that gives hope, fosters empathy, and strengthens the belief in humanity's capacity for good.
Here in /c/UpliftingNews, we uphold the values of respect, empathy, and inclusivity, fostering a supportive and vibrant community. We encourage you to share your positive news, comment, engage in uplifting conversations, and find solace in the goodness that exists around us. We are more than a news-sharing platform; we are a community built on the power of positivity and the collective desire for a more hopeful world. Remember, your small acts of kindness can be someone else's big ray of hope. Be part of the positivity revolution; share, uplift, inspire!
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Simply put, a lot of people hate socialism aka "I'm paying so you can get something for free". I'm all for it.
My 73 year old father supports Trump (not one of the crazy people, just misguided) and hates Biden. He said one of the biggest things that Biden did that pissed him off was student loan forgiveness because my dad said he had to work 3 jobs in the early 70s to put himself through college (which he dropped out of and went into the electrical trade), so everyone else should have to struggle like he did, regardless of the fact that college cost him like $2,000 a semester and it costs like $12-15 grand now, assuming you're not living on campus.
That’s such a sad argument. I heard a great counter to that line. Imagine we discovered a cure for cancer. This line of reasoning would say “well my mom suffered and died of cancer so why should others get a cure?”
My mom’s ghost would slap me so hard if I said that
I can imagine those people saying this
Pretty much.
Cancer is mostly random. Going into debt for school is a choice.
A choice typically made by 17 year old kids after having spent their entire life having it drummed into them that college is the correct step to take after school
Also 17 year old kids, the vast majority of which have never taken on significant debt and have no frame of reference for the scale of obligation they're taking on.
It blows my mind that we look at an 17 year old and, as a government, we say, "Alcohol? Too young and immature. Handguns? Too young and immature. Tobacco products? Too young and immature. Voting? Too young and immature. Enlisting in the military or want to take on 5 or 6 figures of debt that will drive your major life decisions for the next few decades? Sign here."
What causes you to go to school? Generally a hope to fulfill your basic survival functions these days, like eating, safety, and temperature regulation. Are those needs choices?
And what causes having those needs? Being born. Was that one's own choice either?
I think this argument won't work well on those who came of age when a highschool degree would cut it, but it is logically rather sound based on present realities.
I'm a younger millennial and went to school and got a degree. No debt. It's a choice.
I love this argument. Absolutely no empathy for anyone who had different options and experiences, just straight up "I did it so anyone else can too." You're making the world a better place. /s
"Fuck you, I got mine."
I can have empathy for people in different situations than me, but it's not my responsibility to bail them out of their problems.
I really don't understand people who don't want to contribute to an overall better society.
I'm happy to pay more in taxes to have a healthier, better educated, and more stable society. It pays dividends.
I'll just assume your family is penniless, sent you to poorly funded K-12 schools, and kicked you out on your ass onto the street the day you turned 18 with no warning or support of any kind, and you still somehow got a degree without debt.
Otherwise, you'd be a raging hippocrite born on third base crowing like you hit a triple! Clearly though that can't be the case.
I'm sorry your family did you like that though, that's rough.
Well it is if you want a healthy society, other wise sure, every man for himself.
Counter argument: Yes it is. As much as any responsibility exists at all, you have a responsibility to your fellow people.
"Well it's not my responsibility" leads to a shittier world. And since you apparently have a degree and no debt, you can spare the energy to be better.
Or maybe just watch "The Good Place" again.
No?
In fact, you know what? You should just drop out of society, go buy your own island, and declare yourself sovereign. There, you will only ever have to deal with your own choices and problems. You'll never have responsibility for anyone else's, and no one will have responsibility for yours.
The rest of us will be over here enjoying something called civilization, where people join together for their mutual benefit and aid.
You think you're personally paying off other people's student loans? Don't bother answering you're obviously just a troll.
What's your opinion on bailing out Mega Corporations who didn't responsibly save their money? Or is it ok to bail out Mega Corps but not ok to bail out your mechanic?
That is quite a selfish viewpoint. Perhaps reconsider what you mean. Are you really stating that all people should have the same fate as you regardless of their starting conditions?
No. But lots of people are bad financially and get themselves into too much debt without a way out and I don't think I should be responsible for bailing them out.
this is such a delusional and likely spoiled statement
You can always tell when people run out of arguments when people respond to reasonable comments with "OMG I CANT EVEN"
I seem to have struck a nerve, you must be one of the people I'm talking about.
Booo, ok troll spotted never mind my earlier question. I see your game
A 17 year old kid is forced into taking on debt to attend college with, at the time they agree to it, no way of paying it off. It's a gamble any which way you slice it. And they have no frame of reference to understand the decision they're making.
The school isn't on the hook to ensure they get gainful employment that would pay them enough to manage that debt. The loan servicer isn't either. Only the kid is going to be held to anything, yet the shitty take is always, "They knew what they were signing up for, so fuck em. I want them to suffer for their bad decision."
With all sincerity, I hope you encounter misfortune through no fault of your own that ruins your financial security for the next 20 years.
Maybe that'll teach you a little empathy.
No one is forced to go to college. And they definitely aren't forced to attend 50k+/year universities.
No they're not! No is forced to go to college, and no is forced to go into debt to do it! Those are both choices they made! The premise of your whole argument is not true!
Unlikely, I plan ahead and don't make stupid financial decisions.
This shit is bad for society, and by extension you. Loan services and schools suck up vast wealth that... goes into rich pockets and widens the income gap. Money that could go to purchasing goods and services, or supporting businesses of any size, or buying houses, or having kids, or paying taxes that could be used on useful things like decent roads (how taxes are used specifically is outside the scope of this discussion, just an example).
Your whole world could be better through loan forgiveness, just not specific to you. Just everything around you better. Just requires a little less "got mine".
Oh sweet summer child...
You forgot this part of that claim - "And I didn't get help from nobody neither"
I guess you’re against COVID treatments too because coming in contact with other human beings is also a choice. Lung Cancer cure? No thanks, they chose to smoke those cigarettes so I would like them to suffer.
My mom died of Lung Cancer, didn't smoke a single cigarette her whole life. So fuck you.
I don't want them to suffer, but I'm not paying for their treatment.
I'm not trying to be spicy, but you must see how these two statements are contradictory.
No... No they don't lol.
If you have insurance, private or public, you’re paying for them either way. That’s how insurance works.
Nobody wants to pay taxes bud, but if you don't, the country will fall apart around you because of precisely that.
Big L take . Enjoy the ratio
It most certainly did not cost him $2000 per semester in the early 70s. It cost about $2000 for a full year at a private university. Around $500 if he went to a public school.
https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d07/tables/dt07_320.asp
And that's in 2007 money! $500 in 2007 converted to the early 70s is $90 to $100. Minimum wage was $1.60 per hour, so he would have to work 2 weeks at minimum wage to afford public school. 7 weeks for private school.
What a burden! He might have to give up part of his summer!
Yeah, maybe per year, I don't remember.
I hate that THAT is the argument against loan forgiveness. No one is making the actual argument - that this doesn't fix the systemic issues that caused the debt in the first place and will actually make it worse for future generations.
Student loan reform is what we need. Loan forgiveness without reform will cause tuition prices to increase for future generations.
It's millenials doing a "fuck you, gen z, I got mine" and we should be better than that.
Certain states are making tuition free for public universities if you meet their requirements, I know NY State is one of them.
Does he have any grandchildren? Sometimes people feel this way only about “others” and have considerably different feelings about how “we” should be treated.
Yep, a 3, almost 4 year old niece.
And he thinks working 3 jobs will be good for her, right? After all, he turned out great.
Remind him that as parents we're supposed to leave the world a better place for our kids.
Boomers didn't get that memo.
That's why this Gen-Xer is telling him to remind his dad of that lesson.